Grist Feed: How To Talk To A Climate Skeptic

Ask Umbra on combating climate denial

Umbra Fisk — Tue, 15 Sep 2009 20:59:59 -0700

by Umbra Fisk
Reprinted by permission from Grist. For more environmental news, humor, and inspiration, visit www.grist.org.

Send your question to Umbra!

Q. Dear Umbra,

This "year with no summer" and some alleged statistics I have seen quoted about earth-wide temperatures for the last ten years have resulted in claims that the earth is not heating -- it may even be cooling. What about it?

Arthur Waskow
Shalom Center, Philadelphia

A. Dearest Arthur,

The oceans are too getting warmer!That would be great. The planet needs some cooling, and humans certainly aren't doing anything to help. But let us remember the difference between weather and climate.

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration does confirm that summer 2009 in the contiguous U.S. was 0.4 degrees Fahrenheit below the 20th Century average of 72.1 degrees. We notice no concomitant change in policy from the U.S. Global Change Research Program, or any other reputable source, so we must conclude that a cool summer was only weather, and that in general the overall climate remains on track for warming.

After all, the last decades have included the hottest years on record, when you look at ocean and surface temperatures. Last year was the eighth-warmest on record; full stats are not yet in on 2009, of course, but already we know that the world's oceans set a heat record in July. All this does not seem to indicate ten years worth of cooling temperatures.

As our country pushes further toward actually having an organized response to climate change, it's important for us all to be as informed as we can be, and to be ready to respond to those who are dubious about the need for action. Or who write whatever weird stuff you've been reading about cooling temperatures.

I have given out some resources before, and Grist as a whole is a good resource for tracking climate action in senate chambers, chat rooms, and other tangible and intangible locations. But today I'd like to be sure our browser bookmarks contain lists with some helpful easy-to-read FAQ compilations. These are for use when confused by news stories or "deniers," and are mostly organized by the issues deniers raise.

I'll just give a few. There's Grist's own "How to Talk to a Climate Skeptic" series. There's Real Climate's Start Here page as well as their index, and my beloved Union of Concerned Scientists' Climate FAQ list. Britain's Natural Environment Research Council also has a nice summary of an open session it held a few years ago, organized by debate points.

I hope those will help with the confusing moments.

Cheerfully,
Umbra

Related Links:

Grist Feed: How To Talk To A Climate Skeptic

Ask Umbra on combating climate denial

Was there another breathless announcement of another phony record, and another quiet retraction?

‘Global warming comes from within’—Is heat at the Earth’s core the real cause of global warming?

Summer ice in the Arctic has recovered—Was the Arctic ice retreat a climate anomaly?

Is the American Physical Society a crack in the climate change consensus?

Is the IPCC so wrong their theories contradict a basic laws of physics?

In 2008, did temperatures drop as much as they rose over the whole 20th century?

Only if you ignore fossil fuel emissions

‘Climate change mitigation would lead to disaster’—Not really, but this may be lesser of two evils

China and India have joined Kyoto, they just have different obligations, as is morally appropriate

‘Kyoto is a big effort for almost nothing’—Kyoto is only in its first phase

The problem is not how high the temperature may go, but how fast it is changing

‘It’s the sun, stupid’—Very bright, yes, but not getting brighter

‘Historically, CO2 never caused temperature change’—Not so

‘Geological history does not support CO2’s importance’—Just not true

‘CO2 doesn’t lead, it lags’—Turns out CO2 rise is both a cause and an effect of warming

There is no proof in science, but there are mountains of evidence

Water vapor is indeed a powerful greenhouse gas, but there is plenty of room for CO2 to play a role

‘Climate scientists dodge the subject of water vapor’—No, they really don’t

‘We are just recovering from the LIA’—Why should we expect this to happen?