Capitalism is the astounding belief that the most wickedest of men will do the most wickedest of things for the greatest good of everyone.

As quoted in Moving Forward: Programme for a Participatory Economy (2000) by Michael Albert, p. 128

I think the cognitive dissonance is just too much to bear for the Liberterians of the world.

I am a reformed liberterian.

I wonder what their recipe is for dealing with the collapse of fish stocks in unconstrained fisheries.

The currently collapsing of Mediterranian Bluefin Tuna stocks provides a good example. And can be compared well with what happened to Canadian cod stocks (among many many others).

Have you tried using these examples in arguments with Taylor. How does he respond?

It seems to me that there is practically no example of a fishery that does not eventually collapse unless severe controls on capitalist impulses are imposed.

Why would oil be different in their opinion? After all, it doesn't even have the benefit of being able to regenerate itself if we ease of the extraction rate.

Intellectually dishonest arguments are ones full of absurd straw-men, false dichotomies and contemptuously dismissive ad hominems.  You know, like the one you just made.