Support Grist
Support nonprofit, independent environmental journalism.
Donate to Grist.
Main Dish

Desert Flowers

Legendary Burning Man festival gets an eco-conscience

By Judith Lewis
03 Aug 2007
Tools: print | email | discuss | write to the editor | subscribe | RSS
Armen Zeitounian leads the way up the staircase of the house he's living in, a two-story colonial nestled in the smoggy hills north of Los Angeles, complete with a view and a pool and a black Ford Explorer in the driveway. In a room on the top floor, a two-by-six-inch plank, painted white, protrudes about five feet through a hole halfway up the wall; in the next room, the other half of the plank emerges, painted black.

"It's called the No-See-Saw," Zeitounian says. "It's a play on perception and psychological issues. Who are you trusting when you sit down? You don't know. So do you sit down anyway?"

The Burning Man.
The eponymous man.
Photo: Mulling it Over via Flickr
Zeitounian once had a plan to exhibit the No-See-Saw at an outdoor festival in France, reimagining the piece so the plank would jut through a fabricated, free-standing tree. He would call it the "Tseesaw" -- a seesaw in a tree. But last September, when the Burning Man Festival declared that its 2007 art theme, "The Green Man," would examine humanity's relationship to nature, Zeitounian changed his destination. He answered the organization's call for contributors to its 30,000-square-foot "Green Man Pavilion" with a proposal for the Tseesaw. The Burning Man art staff not only approved the project, they gave him "more than a couple of grand" to build it.

Thirty-one years old, with wide green eyes and a mass of curly brown hair gathered in a ponytail, Zeitounian describes himself as a "conscious person," but not an environmentalist. "I'm not one of those Greenpeace types," he assures me. "I recycle as much as I can, and I try to be conscious, but I'm not into alternative-energy vehicles or anything." High on the wall of his studio he displays his basic mantra: "Oh arrogant man!" it says. "You think you can balance nature?"

Nevertheless, when he constructs the Tseesaw on the hardened sands of Nevada's Black Rock Desert (also known as the Playa) this month, he will do it in a way that pleases even the most zealous champion of sustainability: The 24-foot tree and its plank will consist only of recycled cardboard, chipboard, and wood; just a few metal fixings will be new. The resulting Tseesaw, Zeitounian explains, becomes about "the give and take, the Yin and the Yang. It's about a clean environment and pollution; about how we're trying to balance nature and instead end up destroying everything around us."

In the week before Labor Day, when an estimated 40,000 people will gather on a dry lake bed for eight days of big art, music, reckless generosity, and general debauchery, the Tseesaw will take its place in a grove of 16 other art-trees surrounding the iconic wooden man that traditionally burns on the event's final Saturday. Zeitounian calls the exposure -- not just to fellow attendees but to environmental organizations and corporations, which are exhibiting for the first time this year -- "an artist's dream."

An artist's dream, maybe -- but how does it save the planet exactly?

The Road From Ruin


In its 22-year history, Burning Man has always been a place where environmental concerns come second to the more pressing requirements of "radical self-expression," such as building large structures out of brand-new lumber, lighting them on fire, and watching a heat tornado rise out of the flames.

Which doesn't mean it went off all these years without any environmental ethics. Since the event moved to the desert from San Francisco's Baker Beach in 1990, it has labored under constant pressure from authorities to mind its litter, a task that grew more onerous as attendance grew from a few thousand revelers with guns and LSD to tens of thousands, many of them with feather boas, power tools, and kids.

Back in 1998, when the federal Bureau of Land Management threatened to pull the event's permit unless it adhered more closely to conservation policies, the organizers declared the event's first annual theme: Leave No Trace.

"It was through the efforts of the government's Leave No Trace policy that we started to realize the real cost of the event," says Tom Price, an 11-year Playa veteran who this year became Burning Man's very first environmental director. "In the larger culture we fill a landfill and live by the ocean where there's a fresh breeze. On the playa we don't have that luxury. It's a place where your impact is really mirrored back to you."

It wasn't an immediate success. In 1998, a friend and I, both inculcated in Outward Bound ethics, collected eight large garbage bags of trash off the Playa on the "Leave No Trace" event's last day -- some of the crap literally fitting the definition of that word. As I recall, the porta-potties were so clogged with beer bottles that we moved camp one night just to get away from the smell.

Some progress has been made since then: the Bureau of Land Management now proudly heralds Burning Man as the world's largest Leave No Trace event. But the simple phenomenon of 40,000 hard-partying humans occupying ground that sustains no living thing (a bug in this desert is either a stowaway or a miracle) is an act against nature. Here is a place you can blow things up with evident impunity. Burning Man is not an event designed with the local ecology in mind, much less the future of the earth.

That may be about to change.

Despite its history, original intentions, or the objections of the many Burners Who Hate Rules, this year Burning Man's organizers don't just intend for the event to go green; they have dedicated it to solving the world's most alarming environmental problems, from the accumulating waste stream to carbon in the atmosphere.

"It's sort of like rehabilitating an alcoholic," says staffer Paul Schreer, better known by his Playa name, Blue. "They have to hit rock bottom before they can admit there's a problem. Then they swing way to the other extreme."

Rising From the Ashes


Blue piloted the Playa's first biodiesel experiment three years ago. It failed, he admits, when fuel leaked into the generator's crankcase. But he learned a lot -- in particular, that your rental company has to know something about the specific properties of biodiesel if you want the project to work.

This year, instead of asking permission from rental companies to use biodiesel in their equipment, the organization asked those firms to bid for the event's biodiesel-only contract. Every one of the companies obliged. (They settled on Kohler Rentals out of Reno, Nev.; Bently Biofuels will provide fuel produced from waste oil.)

Price calls the biodiesel deal a model example of how consumer choice can change the world: "Because of our repeated insistence and demand, a whole bunch of companies that refused us before said yes now. It's truly amazing."

Similar shifts have happened throughout the festival: In other years, the solution to the escalating trash problem was to order more dumpsters; this year, the various camps of 100 or more -- some of which have long carried green-leaning names like Recycle Camp and the Alternative Energy Zone -- will feature compost bins. Recycling centers in Reno that typically close on Labor Day will stay open to receive Burners' recyclable trash.

Surfing the Belgian Waffle.
Save room for desert.
Photo: john curley via Flickr
And what about generator exhaust, the columns of smoke that rise from burning art, and the RVs, SUVs, and other oil-leakers that transport us all to Black Rock City? Two years ago, a group of environmental consultants -- including Price, a former environmental journalist -- began a project called CoolingMan, to monitor and offset the Playa's carbon load. According to their website, roughly 27,000 tons of carbon billow out of Black Rock City every year -- 30 times more than the amount that emanates from the notoriously carbon-squandering Madonna, who called attention to her private-jet lifestyle when she participated in Live Earth. Cooling Man urges people to donate offsets to help make up for the greenhouse gases wafting into the desert air. Last year they aimed to offset the 100 tons of carbon generated by the Burning Man himself; this year, they're shooting for the whole amount.

Nothing on the Playa this summer, however, will be greener than the art. Last year's masterpiece, the Euchronia project, consisted of a hundred miles of boards arranged into an irregularly shaped cavern. Observers screamed in protest at its spectacular fiery destruction: "You're wasting perfectly good wood!" one woman yelled. "Save the forests!" But in 2007, eco-themed projects have burst forth as if lurking ready-made in some alternate universe, waiting to be born into the world of metal and neon.

They include epic technological wonders like the garbage-to-hydrogen converter Mechabolic and the Single-Cell Solution [PDF], a machine that feeds collected biodiesel exhaust to algae in a pond, and then makes fuel from the algae -- sequestering carbon at the same time that it produces oxygen and fuel. Best of all, perhaps, only the sun will power the lights on the 40-foot man that stands at the center of the city.

"We're addressing solid waste, materials, energy, transportation, art, and media in all aspects of the event," says Price. "We put everything on the table. Who says we can't solve the world's problems while blowing things up and shooting flame throwers in fuzzy pants?"

Man Meets World


Some of those solutions to the world's problems will be exhibited in the Green Man Pavilion, where an unprecedented array of international corporations will display their goods at the rigorously noncommercial event. Price says he's been besieged by critics of the corporate involvement, "even though the terms we've mandated are very strict": The organization still forbids the prominent display of commercial logos and sales of anything but its own coffee, lemonade, and ice.

But Price and other organizers worry more that the event will fade into insignificance if there isn't more cross-pollination with the world at large.

So will this grand Burning Man foray into carbon-conscious stewardship be faultless? No, and that's not the goal. "Five or six months ago I emailed [author and environmentalist] Bill McKibben and said, 'We need to build the 10th-largest city in Nevada from the ground up and do it right. Or wrong,'" Price says. "And he wrote back that the idea of making a temporary city in the desert somehow sustainable is so ridiculous, that it really doesn't matter."

"He said, 'You already know you can't do it -- that's what makes trying, and succeeding in any small way, so great.' And the worst that can happen is that you get a lot of really smart people together who come up with solutions to environmental problems and have fun doing it."

Or you get a lot of really smart people together who come up with solutions to environmental problems and then forget about it until next year. Roger Wilson, the mayor of the Alternative Energy Zone, worries a little that environmentalism will prove a fleeting Burning Man trend, and too many "shoulds" will turn people away from the idea altogether. In the 500-citizen AEZ, generators have been banned since 2001 for the sake of more imaginative projects. (With Wilson's help, I built my first solar generator there in 2003, and powered two scooters with the juice.) The emphasis has always been less about saving the planet than about having fun with low-voltage light-emitting diodes, or hacking Game Boys to pinpoint iridium flares in the big night sky with solar-powered lasers.

"I don't care what people do at Burning Man," Wilson says. "I don't care if they roast their marshmallows over 200 gallons of diesel fuel every day for a week. What matters is what they do when they get home. If you can teach them how to burn things in a green way, that's great, but it's trivial. If you can teach them to be greener the other 51 weeks of the year, that's a big, big accomplishment."

In the end, the greening of the Playa might be understood less as a campaign for the earth and more as a reflection of shifting world opinion. "At least one part of the reason they're doing this is because environmentalism is trendy," Wilson says. "But that's OK. I'm frightened about the world, so I find that delightful."

Tools: print | email | discuss | write to the editor | subscribe | RSS
Judith Lewis covers the environment for the LA Weekly in Los Angeles and blogs at Another Green World. Her work has also appeared in High Country News, Sierra Magazine, and the Los Angeles Times.
< Previous | Next >
Comments: (11 comments)

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have a Gristmill account, log in below. If you don't have a Gristmill account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Username: Password:

Forgot your password? Enter your username and click:

Short shrift for the greeness of Burning Man

I actually think this article gives the green aspects of BM short shrift. When we went last year (was that just last year???), we camped with our Honda Insight hybrid near people with a giant solar toaster, a solar shower, and a biodiesel-fueled bus (a giant one that could've been a band's tour bus). And those were all folks that showed up independent of one another, not as part of some green theme camp.

As a whole, Burning Man does involve a lot of diesel generators and stuff burning up. But it also involves some 40,000 or so people living for up to a week in the desert with only what they brought with them. So on an individual level, it inspires an attitude of living with low energy use and extreme water conservation. Just like a long backpacking trip, for most people the Burning Man experience is largely about getting by with less ... and that can translate back to the homefront, too.

Sure, there are those folks that show up with the tractor-trailers, the diesel generators, the giant sound systems, and the i-don't-know-how-many-watt green lasers. But off the main concourse, most of the participants are getting by with as little as possible, and that experience can leave a lasting impact on the psyche.


A celebration of...

... wanton destruction of natural resources and pumping CO2 into the atmosphere like there's no tomorrow. All for entertainment.

Symbolic of the American lifestyle... justified by a few carbon offsets! Symbolic of the absurdity of offsets!

And then there is that other underlying assumption... its just a desert... no problem if thousands of people trample thin desert varnish (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desert_varnish) again and again and again... while they watch tons of carbon go into the atmospere. The prairie is just a bunch of grass... till it. The arctic is a wasteland... drill it. The desert is barren... drive wherever you wish. Destroy the surface. Disrupt animal life. But please don't litter. What a joke!!!

And next...

British Petroleum creates "Performance Art Beach"!!!

Tens of thousands of people celebrate as refineries dump thousands of tons of toxic waste into Lake Michigan! It is said to be a commentary on modern civilization's destruction of nature.

They assure environmentalists that the toxic waste is, well, waste. So it is okay to just dump it. They'll plant some trees in Africa to compensate for some of the environmental damge, but point out that Lake Michigan is not really a natural environment anymore.

Environmentalists go wild, dancing nude next to the glowing water. Covered live over the internet, the dumping of toxic waste generates awareness of the Earth's fragile ecosystems and donations to conservation organizations increase by 6% that month. It might kill a few fish, but it is good for  the world, say one party goer.

British Petroleum promises an even LARGER event next year. Or perhaps a weekly event... that way fewer people will converge on the site at one time.

Executive urge people to please remove their trash at the end of the event and recycle all glass and plastic bottles.

Further more...

Angry Environmentalists Protest!

27 angry, carrot wielding environmentalists have chained themselves to the Burning Man perimeter trash fence in protest of the 2007 "green" event.

Wiscidea,  founder and leader of the militant group, Twisted Knickers for the Extinction of Humankind, kindly took time out of pelting passers by with organically grown produce to answer a few questions.

Q: Wiscidea, It seems that a gathering of people from all corners of the globe for the purpose of global change and sustainability, among other topics, would be just the type of catalyst that's needed to make big changes in a quickly deteriorating environment. Why are you protesting?

A: Well, Jim, in the process of showcasing new technologies for sustainable energy, and educating revelers about being green, these people are USING fossil fuels, eating MEAT, and wasting precious resources such as recycled materials and scrap metal on ART! This is completely unacceptable.

Q:Hmm...OK. So do you think that groups that have arisen from this festival like Burners Without Borders (http://www.burnerswithoutborders.org/), who help build homes with recycled materials for those in New Orleans, are not a sustainable and far reaching result of this "waste of fuel"?

A: Many thousands of gallons of fuel are used as a result of this un-responsible, despicable, and unclean event. That's not worth the relief given to those families.

Q: Ahh...So then, do not all of the people attending this event burn fossil fuels, turn on lights, use their computers, and generally use more energy than they produce every day at home? Wouldn't they be most likely using an equivalent amount of energy living their daily lives during this same week, if they weren't here?

A: Well...that doesn't count. They aren't naked and/or partying and happy at home.

Q: I see. So do you think the burning art at the festival holds a candle (in terms of carbon output) to the thousand plus forest fires that burn each year during the dry seasons in the South West, as a result of over zealous fire suppression techniques that have been used for the last 50 years?

A: Those are God's fault.

Interesting. Well thanks for your time (dodging an organic tomato). Have fun being chained to your fence.

hee hee hee

Good one AZTommyB!!!

I'm just saying... seems a bit hypocritical justifying the burning of vast quantities of wood and trampling a desert by the suggestion that it will raise awareness of environmental and social justice issues.

How's this different from BP saying they have to pollute in order to ensure there are jobs for people? OR GW saying its okay to kill people to bring democracy to a country?

I thought "environmentalists" were generally looking for ways to reduced frivilous CO2 emissions. I did not realize that is was okay for them to pollute, but not okay for others who might be able to justify their decision to emit CO2.

I'm looking for a consistent message... otherwise, no one will take a person serious when they do criticize polluters.

By then way... I enjoyed your description of me, since I'm not an environmentalist, not a vegetarian, do not approve of militant behavior, would never chain myself to a fence for any cause, enjoy my commuting lifestyle, support the use of GMOs, and do not believe there is a God according to the common definition of God.

One thing I do believe in is NOT condemning people for engaging in behavior one seems willing to engage in themselves... like complaining about coal plants emitting CO2 while you set fire to an enormous pile of wood. It really is, in my opinion, absurd.

It is nice that the Burning Man people are motivated to do great things, but why so much destruction first? Why not just get together to do great things?

Consistency. Consistency. Consistency.

Forget the Green at the festival site

The overwhelming environmental cost of the festival is people driving there and back. Any greening of the festival itself is a drop in the bucket compared to the transportation carbon costs.  Just for one number, a gallon of gasoline produces 19 lbs of CO2

Short of canceling the festival and celebrating it online, the organizers should charter buses from nearby cities, and urge attendees to pay for and use these buses. Or at least organize car pools.

Dysfunction grows to consume all the money made available to combat it. -- Theodore Dalrymple

in the spirit of one-upmanship

Glad to see a good sport. Thanks!

This festival, by nature, is about people and personable freedom. This year, this person-centric festival is shifting it's focus and energy toward natural responsibilities. As such, I'm so glad that all of these folks are turning their efforts, considerable talents, and amazing wealth of problem solving abilities toward the environmental problems that we as a modern society now face.

Is this festival, in and of itself  saving our environment? No...not even close. It is, however,  creating an attitude of awareness. It's placing a stage in front of many sharp and focused individuals, and it's saying...Show off! How would you fix the problems? What can you do?

Where else do normal people the world over have an opportunity (excuse?) to show their useful ideas of responsible living to so many? They really aren't complaining...they're working on solutions!

I'm excited that there's a venue that will allow unbridled ingenuity to be displayed without mountains of paperwork, lengthy approval processes, and stifling pessimism.

For every worthwhile thing, there is a cost. This is money, time and environmental resources well spent.

oh yeah....and it's way fun :)

Hmmm....

Perhaps someone can get David Roberts to blog live from the next Burning Man festival. Now that would be a fine site to see. I would wade through a bazillion pop-up ads to read his inspired prose describing the dawn of a new culture.

What would happen if humans vanished?

Great feed on fora.tv:

"What would happen if humans vanished? Weisman has created a view of our planet as it would be if we suddenly disappeared. What damage has been done? What part of humankind's creativity would survive? How would Earth's other species fare?

To find an answer, Weisman interviewed scientists from various fields."

Click to View Program
 http://rs6.net/tn.jsp?t=qpgvadcab.0.9kcqddcab.dyrel7bab.8 ...

Texeme.Construct(Participant)

burning, man

As someone who's lived w/the BM festival since 1987 I believe I can say it really has done an outstanding job of minimizing its impact on the Black Rock desert, & is a really terrific venue for opening minds, bodies & souls to the desert, dessert, & desire of people to interact more personally w/their environment.  Anyone who can spend a day or 2 (to say nothing of a week!) on the playa with the sun, dust, wind, night chill & day heat without murder, theft, or cruelty in a population that now numbers 30K+ is transformed to some extent.  The festival itself has years of demonstrated 'leave-no-trace': check out the local newspapers, folks, in conservative northern NV... There is much to be said for anything that enhances humans' closeness to nature, & the Burning Man festival brings out a lot of good in a lot of people.  & it can all lead to greater empathy w/the world, & less destruction... Humans are a natural part of the environment, too, & so is their interaction: why not celebrate such a positive one?

While this may not be the party you hoped for, while we're here we might as well dance!
a celebration of...

I checked out the link to Wikipedia's 'desert varnish' and learned that it actually grows on rocks!  Any burner can tell you that there are no rocks on the playa.  It's an ancient lakebed in which nothing (not even hardy desert plants) grows due to the high-alkaline dust.  Sure, BM can be more environmentally friendly, but I challenge anyone to find a festival of this size anywhere that does as little harm to the environment.  As pointed out by other writers, consciousness is being raised at BM, not only on environmental issues but a whole host of social issues.  I particular like gift economy as an alternative to capitalism, in which a community based on caring and sharing is fostered.  In balance, Burning Man is good for the planet!

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have a Gristmill account, log in below. If you don't have a Gristmill account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Username: Password:

Forgot your password? Enter your username and click:

The comments of Grist users reflect the opinions of those individuals only, and do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of Grist, its staff, its board members, their psychotherapists, or their aestheticians. Got it?


Also in Grist

The Week's Most Popular



From the Archives
All You Need Is Lovins, by David Roberts. A conversation with energy guru Amory Lovins.

ADVERTISING POLICY


About Grist | Support Grist | Job Board | Archives | Grist by Email | RSS | Podcast
Gristmill Blog | In the News | Ask Umbra | Muckraker | Victual Reality | Weekly Recipes | The Grist List | The Bottom Line



Grist: Environmental News and Commentary
a beacon in the smog (tm) ©2008. Grist Magazine, Inc. All rights reserved. Gloom and doom with a sense of humor®.
Webmaster | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Trademarks