A Whale of a Crime

U.S. denounces Iceland whaling move 7

WASHINGTON—The United States on Friday denounced Iceland’s decision to go ahead with a sharply higher whaling quota, voicing concern there were not whales to sustain the hunt.

Iceland’s new left-wing government said last week it will maintain an earlier decision for a quota of 150 fin and 150 minke whales this year—a sixfold increase—despite international calls for it to reconsider.

The U.S. State Department said it “strongly opposes” the decision.

“We are deeply concerned that stocks of fin and minke whales are not adequate to support this harvest,” it said in a statement.

“We call upon the government of Iceland to rescind this decision and to focus on the long-term conservation of whale stocks, rather than on the short-term interests of its whaling industry,” it said.

The United States also said the decision would undermine ongoing talks on the future of the International Whaling Commission.

The IWC reform talks are part of a U.S.-led drive to reduce tensions around close ally Japan, which infuriates Australia and New Zealand by killing hundreds of whales each year in the Antarctic Ocean.

Japan says it abides by a 1986 IWC moratorium on commercial whaling as it uses a loophole that allows “lethal research” on the ocean giants, with the meat then heading to restaurants and supermarkets.

Norway and Iceland defy the moratorium altogether.

Iceland’s new government came to office after the global financial crisis ravaged the economy of the island, which became the first Western European nation in three decades to need a bailout from the International Monetary Fund.

The new government includes parties opposed to whaling, but it said it was maintaining the new whaling quota because it concluded it was legally bound to it.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Wolverine Posted 2:43 am
    28 Feb 2009

    Split In Progressive PoliticsThe Icelandic government is a perfect example of anti-environmental leftists.  This is why priorities are so important.  It's not just whether people support or oppose certain ideas or actions, it's just as important what priority people give to a certain issue.  Those who don't prioritize the environment are not environmentalists, even if they support good environmental goals.
  2. naturallyinteresting Posted 6:43 am
    02 Mar 2009

    Minke PopulationsMinke populations in the Northeast Atlantic are estimated to be around 103,000 (95% confidence interval, IWC Scientific Committee 2008). Norway is setting annual quotas around 1000.
    For a 116,362 population size assuming 3% MSYR, MSY is 1,388. With 2% MSYR, MSY is reduced to 936.
    It appears that Minke are being harvested at close to MSY. Rather than pursuing a harmful ban on whaling, whale populations would benefit from increased populations studies, and agreements between nations setting quotas at MEY.
  3. caniscandida Posted 8:49 am
    02 Mar 2009

    Way wrongHarpoons away!  Blood in the water!  Yay humanity!
    Regardless of environmental ethics, whatever exactly they may be, there is NOTHING justifiable about the slaughter of cetaceans.
  4. Pompey Road Posted 9:07 am
    02 Mar 2009

    Kill them all quickly:With all the pollution run off from the U.S. into the Oceans and the rest of the world, why not just kill them quick. Would be more merciful than the slow death they are going to experience. We also kill more whales with Navy sonar than this hunt will. From a country that destroys the habitat of scores of creatures and whole deciduous mountain regions who are we to lecture.
    Harpoon or red tide, what's the difference, they are still dead.
  5. caniscandida Posted 5:10 pm
    02 Mar 2009

    "more merciful"Alas, you might be right, Pompey.  All the garbage floating around in all the oceans is a horrible artefact of our civilization.
  6. amazingdrx Posted 11:28 pm
    02 Mar 2009

    We who are closerTo our end than our start need to try and keep as much of our bioshpere as possible from following us into the great beyond.  That's zen, it goes beyond simple human reasoning.  Auuum.
  7. Pompey Road Posted 12:00 am
    03 Mar 2009

    Dimensions:and while we are in this realm, like a bird throuth the air and a fish through the water...

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement