Grist — A Beacon in the Smog

  • Hot Topics:
  • Ask Umbra
  • Grist TV
  • SXSW
  • Gross food
  • Bluefin tuna ban
  • Follow Grist:
  • What can China teach us about electric bikes?
  • Has Big Organic passed its sell-by date?
  • One year later, a Happy Meal doesn't decompose
    • Log in or Register
  • Climate & Energy
  • Food
  • Living
  • Politics
  • Placemaking
  • Business
  • News

Unstoppable disinformation every 15 minutes from Fred Singer

Climate denier contradicts self, facts, remains famous 23

avatar for Joseph Romm

by Joseph Romm

21 Jan 2008 10:12 AM

Read More About
books, Climate & Energy, climate change skepticism
  • Print
post a comment + view comments 23
  • Print

Related Stories

Comments Subscribe by RSSPost a Comment +

  1. avatar for JohnMashey
    • JohnMashey 1859
    • 21 Jan 2008 3:41am 1200915681 1200944481

    Singer is quite consistentI have a copy of Singer's "Hot Talk Cold Science" Revised 2nd Edition, 1999.  My copy of "Unstoppable Global Warming" is currently mislaid, but I recall that between the two books Singer was quite consistent in his bottom line conclusion, quoted here from p.91 of the first book:
    "Policies to limit CO2 emissions by energy or carbon taxes, while superficially attractive, are economically damaging to the great majority of countries..."
    Now, the rationale for this, and the scientific unreasoning, have changed often, but never the bottom line... :-)

    -John Mashey

    • Permalink
    X
  2. avatar for GreenOx
    • GreenOx 2852
    • 21 Jan 2008 4:33am 1200918810 1200947610

    Kansas and Global Warmin'I got a huge crack out of your post, Joseph, but it doesn't surprise me one bit...
    I am from Kansas but currently studying climate change at Oxford for a masters degree, and I am constantly amazed at the idiocy of the vast majority of our legislators in my home state. While I love it dearly, quotes like the following from Melvin Neufeld, the Speaker of the Kansas House of Representatives don't give me much confidence in that body's ability to address
    the issue: "They tell us that if you jog two miles you emit more carbon dioxide than if you drive two miles."
    Are you serious?! I mean, I know Melvin is a bit old, but COME ON!
    Luckily, Governor Kathleen Sebelius and Lt. Governor Mark Parkinson just GET IT. As you mentioned, they took a huge step in denying permits to Sunflower Electric to built two 700-MW coal-fired plants near Holcomb last fall, and are taking HUGE steps toward making Kansas a world leader in wind energy. I think you will continue to see great things from those two leaders - and they are truly leaders - in the current legislative session and throughout the rest of their term.
    And, you're right, Joseph - I don't think anyone in the scientific community takes Fred Singer seriously. Let's hope the Kansas Legislature refuses to take him seriously, as well!
    -GreenOx

    http://www.greenox.blogspot.com

    -GreenOx
    http://www.greenox.blogspot.com
      ...read more

    • Permalink
    X
  3. avatar for GreyFlcn
    • GreyFlcn 1746
    • 21 Jan 2008 5:01am 1200920496 1200949296

    Speaking of whichGrist's "how to talk to a climate skeptic" hasn't really been updated in the past year.
    Stuff like:


    Mars (NASA findings of massive dust storms, why Abrusimov is wrong, and how the mars rover nearly got killed by the storms)

    Nothing on the Lezpig, Lezpig mkII, Canada 100 scientists, or Inhofe 400 scientists

    None of the new admissions by the IPCC, or new studies finding that MAYBE their sea level rise figures were understated.



    http://www.celsias.com/2008/01/21/melting-from-pole-to-po ...



    Most of the new stuff in by Lomborg/Nordhaus

    Never have seen a page with a good explanation of Milankovitch cycles, why solar forced warming can't explain current warming, and how GHG can explain current warming.  (This is one of our weakest arguments, so we need a very understandable argument for it)

    How we know the CO2 is manmade

    Info on why 2006 hurricanes were weak

    Info on Gore's "Errors" by a UK judge, and the difference between Errors and "Errors"

    Why 1934 really wasn't the hottest year on earth

    Polar Bears

    NAS review of Mann et al. didn't discredit it

    Moberg 2005

    Baliunas 2006 / Singer 2006

    Svensmark 2007

    The issues with the Troposphere, and how John Christy continues to lie about it.

    James Hansen isn't being bribed by George Soros



    etc.
    And then just in general, clumps of counter arguments:

    The alleged "errors" in An Inconvenient Truth

    The real errors in Great Global Warming Swindle
      ...read more

    • Permalink
    X
  4. avatar for Sam Wells
    • Sam Wells 1754
    • 21 Jan 2008 7:23am 1200929015 1200957815

    Poleward ice starting to go?A wee bit off topic, but some recent scoop says that the Antarctic is losing lots of ice on the western side near the Ross Shelf ... a volcano was discovered, and "lakes of water" exist under the pack ice that when warmed, could really melt it fast. Not sure if I got the stories right but they're dramatic and attention-grabbing.
    Meanwhile in the Arctic, sea ice formation is extremely thin and likely to melt even faster next summer (source:  Jeff
    Master's blog, highly respected).  
    Good article, Mr. Romm. If there was some BS it was about whether CO2 was man-made, which obviously not all is. It should be noted that the generalized models are only capable of measuring increases in anthropogenic CO2, which in turn increases CO2 concentration in the atmosphere, all other things being equal.
    Unfortunately, the only way one can portray a "model" to a redneck is to show a cardboard cut-out of Farrah Fawcett with her tits falling off....

    Onward through the fog
      ...read more

    • Permalink
    X
  5. avatar for Delay And Deny
    • Delay And Deny 1745
    • 21 Jan 2008 7:36am 1200929776 1200958576

    Joseph Romm...Scientist?

    Well, reading the Wikipedia article on Joseph Romm.   He is obviously a smart and impressive guy...but a scientist?
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_J._Romm
    I would say he is a pundit, a policy maker, a political technology advisor...but I don't see any primary scientific research to his credit?

    Viva la Climate Resistance!

    • Permalink
    X
  6. avatar for JohnMashey
    • JohnMashey 1859
    • 21 Jan 2008 7:45am 1200930344 1200959144

    Good sourcesI've gotten good use of:

    http://www.skepticalscience.com/argument.php
    Which could also use some updating, but is well-organized.  In particular:


    one page that lists all the arguments tersely in one place.  If you can get someone undecided to read that page, it's fairly powerful.
    Links to a page apiece that describe the argument, point at who uses it, show why it's wrong, and point at relevant articles.


    The terse item #s and codes make it easy not to waste
    space, which is very important in letters to editor and postings on websites that have constrained wordcount, where denialists are advantaged by the relative ease of causing confusion versus creating clarity.
    One can easily write: Ho-hum, standard debunked arguments #3, 7, 10 from the website. Ntohing new, and if you have any doubt, look at the scientific references the detailed web pages.
    That tends to derail incitements to long discussions that make it look liek there's a real argument.
    Here's a usage example, in a site with a tightly-constrained word-count:

    http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest ...

    -John Mashey
      ...read more

    • Permalink
    X
  7. avatar for Delay And Deny
    • Delay And Deny 1745
    • 21 Jan 2008 7:59am 1200931141 1200959941

    Your Gonna Need an Ocean, of Calumine Lotion...You're kidding right?
    http://www.skepticalscience.com/global-warming-positives- ...
    Here's one of the agricultural negatives of global warming.

    Rampant, more virulent poison ivy

    AGWers are scraping the tarmac...better land and refuel, with some real science!

    Viva la Climate Resistance!

    • Permalink
    X
  8. avatar for stevenearlsalmony
    • stevenearlsalmony 1765
    • 22 Jan 2008 12:01am 1200988862 1201017662

    For the sake of a future for our children................. choose the good works of Joe Romm rather than the contrived, yet consistent thinking of Fred Singer.  
    Saying the same things over and over, as climate change denialists are known for doing, makes these naysayers perverse, not right.
    Steven Earl Salmony

    AWAREness Campaign on The Human Population, established 2001

    http://sustainabilitysoutheast.org/

    • Permalink
    X
  9. avatar for BrianValentine
    • BrianValentine 2039
    • 23 Jan 2008 2:12am 1201083143 1201111943

    Remains famousI should hope so, as he has contributed a lot.  
    Thanks to the lectures from Dr Singer of some 20-25 years ago, I had the opportunity to learn the fundamental bases of heat and mass exchange - of how the atmosphere actually works.  
    How many reading here can consider an atmospheric phenomenon - and say, yes, I do understand?  

    • Permalink
    X
  10. avatar for amazingdrx
    • amazingdrx 1744
    • 23 Jan 2008 2:29am 1201084186 1201112986

    Prime exampleSinger is a perfect example of "science" for sale.  Of course, once it is sold, it is no longer  science.
    Industry pays a shill like Singer to lie, then industry shilling legislators have him testify.  It's a great system.  It's called corporatism.
    The GOP model of government efficiency.

    http://amazngdrx.blogharbor.com/blog

    • Permalink
    X
  11. Comments Page 1 of 3 pages |  1 2 3 >
1269227035

Post a Comment

Oh no! You’re late to the party - we’re no longer accepting comments on this story.

Related Stories

Advertisement

Most Popular Posts

Viewed
  • A Happy Meal still looks ‘fresh’ on its first birthday image A Happy Meal still looks ‘fresh’ on its first birthday
  • The (almond) joy of cooking your own candy bar image The (almond) joy of cooking your own candy bar
  • Four obstacles facing electric bike popularity image Four obstacles facing electric bike popularity
  • Why we shouldn’t bury bluefin tuna just yet image Why we shouldn’t bury bluefin tuna just yet
  • Nations now free to fish bluefin tuna to extinction image Nations now free to fish bluefin tuna to extinction
Commented
  • Why environmentalists should get involved in immigration reform image Why environmentalists should get involved in immigration reform
  • Four obstacles facing electric bike popularity image Four obstacles facing electric bike popularity
  • A Happy Meal still looks ‘fresh’ on its first birthday image A Happy Meal still looks ‘fresh’ on its first birthday
  • Nations now free to fish bluefin tuna to extinction image Nations now free to fish bluefin tuna to extinction
  • Why aren’t climate scientists talking about healthcare reform? image Why aren’t climate scientists talking about healthcare reform?

Recent Comments

Advertisement
Advertisement
Grist — A Beacon in the Smog

©2010. Grist Magazine, Inc. All rights reserved. Gloom and doom with a sense of humor®.

Sections
  • Politics
  • Climate & Energy
  • Food
  • Business
  • Living Green
  • Placemaking
  • More Topics
Columns
  • Ask Umbra
  • Victual Reality
  • Farmer's Daughter
  • Checkout Line
  • Green State
The Fine Print
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Trademarks
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs at Grist
  • Advertising
  • Pressroom