Stossel 8

Does John Stossel have the brains God gave a chicken wing? Most people say no. Some say yes. One thing's for sure: the debate isn't over!

David Roberts is staff writer for Grist. You can follow his Twitter feed at twitter.com/drgrist.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Biodiversivist's avatar

    Biodiversivist Posted 3:19 pm
    23 Oct 2007

    That imbecile gives me the shivers.He's a parrot. Never had an original thought in his life.

    In the end, it all comes down to biodiversity. Poison Darts--Protecting the biodiversity of our world
  2. GreyFlcn Posted 4:26 pm
    23 Oct 2007

    HehThey keep hammering the IPCC lowball estimate on sea level rise.
    Also notice they cut off Al Gore's statement.

    He was referring that if Greenland all melted, sea level would go up 20ft. Which is true by anyone's measure.
    Gore doesn't give a "When" that will occur.
    However given the fact that the glacier melting speed has doubled in the past 6 years, thats certainly something to think about.
  3. GreyFlcn Posted 4:32 pm
    23 Oct 2007

    Now does this sound familiar?http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jn8RFLZyr-o
  4. justlou Posted 9:47 pm
    23 Oct 2007

    You Won't Finda real debate on Stoessel's program, for sure.  
    Stoessel is a real pro with the PR spin.  It is amazing that ABC tolerates his very one sided commentary presented in a news format.  
    One thought about the link between temperature rise and CO2 levels:  Does it really matter which comes first?  If we are now raising temperatures by increasing CO2 levels we could be compounding the problem -- high CO2 results in the release of more CO2 as a consequence of temperature rise.    Ominously, these events seem to be revealed by sharp spikes in the graphs depicting CO2 and temperature rises.  
    Unfortunately, the idea of tipping points has not been grasped by many people who think that we can adapt to slowly rising temperatures and sea levels.  But, judging from prior climate history, this "wished for" soft landing may be just a self delusion that is being propagated by sock puppets like Stoessel who merely view the data as a weapon to defeat the messenger, Al Gore.  
    The very worst thing we could do is to keep pouring more man made CO2 into the atmosphere during a rise in earth temperature.  The following report by Joseph Romm explaining the link with CO2 saturation in ocean waters is a critical case pointing toward a potentially catastrophic tipping point.  
  5. KenG Posted 10:53 pm
    23 Oct 2007

    Does it matter?From above:
    "One thought about the link between temperature rise and CO2 levels:  Does it really matter which comes first? "
    Actually, it is a critical issue if you are benchmarking climate change computer modeling. The recent speculation about rising temperatures limiting the ocean ability to hold CO2 would provide a theoretical basis for a "CO2 follows temperature" relationship if global temperature is more governed by another effect such as solar activity. This may not be the most popular interpretation at the moment but it does have more basis than idle speculation.
    I have reservations about the accuracy in dating and magnitude of any of these historical temperature and CO2 records but that just reinforces that all these versions are still theories and points out the hyperbole in Gores assertion that the debate is over.
  6. justlou Posted 11:25 pm
    23 Oct 2007

    None of thisdiscounts the idea that continuing to add CO2 at the rates we are now in the face of undisputed temperature rises is just insane.  There should be no debate about this.  Nor should there be any debate about the necessity to wean ourselves off of fossil fuels, global warming or no global warming.  
  7. GreyFlcn Posted 2:43 am
    24 Oct 2007

    Well thats the trick thoughWell thats the trick though.
    It's a false dichotomy.
    Solar intensity was the initial driver of glaciation cycles, via Milankovitch cycles.
    However what they goad you into thinking is that it can't be BOTH the Sun and CO2 working in tandem.
    _
    What they also want you to believe is that solar activity is the reason for the current warming.
    But it can't be.  Because we've been measuring the solar activity for 40 years with multiple sets of satellites, and the solar activity has practically flatlined since then.
    http://greyfalcon.net/solar.png
  8. GreyFlcn Posted 2:48 am
    24 Oct 2007

    Lol, here we gohttp://youtube.com/watch?v=mPgI-7hTZkQ

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement