Can't We All Just Get a Lungfish?

Allocating individual quotas could save many fisheries, study says 4

Retooling the way fisheries are managed could be the key to their long-term health, according to a new study published in the journal Science. Typical fisheries have mostly relied on a free-for-all style of management where scientists determine the overall allowable catch and then fishers go out and compete with each other to try to catch as much as they can as quickly as they can before an overall quota is met or exceeded in a given season. However, the study suggests that might not be the best way to keep fisheries healthy. Instead, it recommends a system of long-term individual quotas for each fisherperson that guarantees them access to a certain percentage of the aquatic bounty. "Under open access, you have a free-for-all race to fish, which ultimately leads to collapse," said Christopher Costello of the University of California at Santa Barbara. "But when you allocate shares of the catch, then there is an incentive to protect it." According to the study, allocating individual shares cuts in half the likelihood that a given fishery will collapse, especially if catch limits are set at responsible levels.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Wolverine Posted 2:47 am
    20 Sep 2008

    Socialism Of The SeasI love it!  This study is a great example of what's wrong with the everyone-for-himself attitude of Americans and other proponents of crapitalism and why socialism is better.  While I don't care much about economics, I realized long ago that we'll never solve any serious ecological problems without getting rid of capitalism, because it causes a rapacious attitude toward the natural environment, which the rapists consider to be merely "resources."
  2. naturescene Posted 2:06 am
    22 Sep 2008

    not socialism, marketsWolverine,
    I believe you're overlooking the fact that this proposal is advocating a market-based system for fisheries, in which individuals are allocated quotas, but the quotas are transferable.  In other words, it's a market-based cap-and-trade for fisheries.
    Sorry to burst your bubble.
  3. Antoinette Posted 2:07 am
    22 Sep 2008

    SE AlaskaHas had this figured out for awhile - Individual Fishing Quotas work very well for sustainability purposes. The quotas fluctuate slightly with abundance year-year.  Halibut and Black Cod have been managed that way for awhile  -- which is why they are the best fish out there to buy both for you health and the environment! Not to mention your taste buds.
  4. naturescene Posted 4:22 am
    22 Sep 2008

    ITQsSome environmental economists have promoted ITQs for years, and fisheries in Alaska and New Zealand showed signs of success.  It's good to hear this concept becoming more mainstream.

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement