Museum meddling

Republican war on science, edition MMCCCVIII 3

Surprised?

Some government scientists have complained that officials at the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History took steps to downplay global warming in a 2006 exhibit on the Arctic to avoid a political backlash, according to documents obtained by The Washington Post.

The museum's director, Cristian Samper, ordered last-minute changes to the exhibit's script to add "scientific uncertainty" about climate change, according to internal documents and correspondence.

Scientists at other agencies collaborating on the project expressed in e-mails their belief that Smithsonian officials acted to avoid criticism from congressional appropriators and global-warming skeptics in the Bush administration. But Samper said in an interview last week that "there was no political pressure -- not from me, not from anyone."

Samper put the project on hold for six months in the fall of 2005 and ordered that the exhibition undergo further review by higher-level officials in other government agencies. Samper also asked for changes in the script and the sequence of the exhibit's panels to move the discussion of recent climate change further back in the presentation, records also show. The exhibit opened in April 2006 and closed in November of that year.

The Post obtained a hand-scrawled note by a curator on the project indicating there was "concern that scientific uncertainty hasn't come out enough." Edits to a "final script" show notations about where to add "the idea of scientific uncertainty about climate research."

Right. I guess we're supposed to believe that this had nothing to do with Dick Cheney's service, as part of his vice presidential duties, on the Smithsonian's board of regents. And nothing to do with the fact that six other regents are appointed by the President Pro-Tempore of the Senate -- at the time Ted Stevens (R-Alaska) -- and the Speaker of the House -- at the time Dennis Hastert (R-Ill.).

Nothing unusual here! At any rate, D.C. residents have other, better options if they want to learn about global warming from a museum exhibit.

Brian Beutler is a contributing writer for Grist as well as Washington correspondent for The Media Consortium. In his spare time he writes an eponymous blog.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Delay And Deny's avatar

    Delay And Deny Posted 1:21 pm
    16 Nov 2007

    Interaction

    I reviewed the Smithsonians plans for the exhibit and my criticism is that they are biting off little more than they can chew.
    I suggest they present an exhibit about Climate Modelling.   Have a bank of computers that feature the climate models.  Let kids (and adults) sit down and run the numbers, allowing them to see how various inputs affect the outcomes.
    Oh, and by the way...if Grist wants a soapbox, how about making all the code for the climate models Open Source and GPL'd?
    Why do the climate modellers have to hide?



    My Log
  2. stevenearlsalmony Posted 3:51 am
    17 Nov 2007

    another example of intellectual dishonesty?Perhaps the following link will provide some perspective........
    http://www.ajc.com/opinion/content/opinion/stories/2007/1 ...
    Steven Earl Salmony

    AWAREness Campaign on The Human Population

    http://sustainabilitysoutheast.org/
  3. stevenearlsalmony Posted 5:02 am
    17 Nov 2007

    Are many leaders hiding the truth?Too many of our politicians, economists, big-business execs and the talking heads in the mass media are all "whistling the same tune."  What is even worse is the way they entice appointees and surrogates to whistle that same tune, too.  After all, who can resist offerings of great wealth, power and privileges that accrue to those who go along with what is political convenient, economically expedient, religiously tolerated and socially agreeable.
    Not only are too many leaders hiding the truth, they are also actively poisoning the well of public discourse in the process. And for what? Evermore power, wealth and privileges for themselves and their minions so they can carefreely play out the "conspicuous consumption fantasies" of their "Me Generation" by living long, living large and living unsustainably, come what may, having forgotten how human life depends upon Earth's limited resources and frangible ecosystem services for its very existence.
    Steven Earl Salmony

    AWAREness Campaign on The Human Population

    http://sustainabilitysoutheast.org/
     

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement