Melbourne

A modern city can be remade 12

Check out this great video of the street life in Melbourne, Australia, which is my new Place I Want to Move:

From the accompanying post on StreetFilms:

Melbourne is simply wonderful. You can get lost in the nooks and crannies that permeate the city. As you walk you feel like free-flowing air with no impediments to your enjoyment. For a city with nearly 4 million people, the streets feel much like the hustle and bustle of New York City but without omnipresent danger and stress cars cause.

There is an invaluable lesson here. In the early '90s, Melbourne was hardly a haven for pedestrian life until Jan Gehl was invited there to undertake a study and publish recommendations on street improvements and public space. Ten years after the survey's findings, Melbourne was a remarkably different place thanks to sidewalk widenings, copious tree plantings, a burgeoning cafe culture, and various types of car restrictions on some streets. Public space and art abound. And all of this is an economic boom for business.

This Streetfilm is vitally important in another way: Melbourne is a new world city, it has a modern grid much like a typical American metropolis. Naysayers who do not believe a city can be radically transformed say that the already narrow streets of many European cities make it easier to have good pedestrian environments there. Melbourne proves that isn't necessarily so.

David Roberts is staff writer for Grist. You can follow his Twitter feed at twitter.com/drgrist.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Jon Rynn's avatar

    Jon Rynn Posted 6:54 am
    07 May 2008

    The future of streets......pedestrians, bikes, and light rail, oh yeah!
  2. ClickClickClank Posted 10:25 am
    07 May 2008

    As someone who lives there...I'd make the following points;


    While not as far along with bicycle infrastructure as some European cities, Melbourne is definitely more bicycle friendly than most. I think this is mainly due to cycling having the best dollar:impact ratio when trying to tackle problems such as pollution, congestion, public health etc etc. The 'Copenhagen' style bike lanes (parked cars and concrete divider between bike lane and traffic) are especially awesome.
    The trams are great, but the public transport system as a whole sucks. When it was government owned we had conductors - now that it's privatised we have a lousy machine based ticketing system so easy to evade the companies were forced to hire 'ticket inspectors' to rough up snotty kids. Do they consider bringing back the conductors? Nope. Instead the government labours them with ANOTHER crappy ticketing system that has suffered ridiculous delays and insane budget blowouts.
    The laneways and 'hidden treasures' stuff is actually pretty accurate. Take a wrong turn down a laneway and there's usually a bar or cafe at the end of it.
    The video doesn't mention our problems with the homeless, the mentally ill, the current proposed '2am lockout' for bars and pubs because stupid people can't control themselves in public, the housing crisis, the overall transport nightmare that the state of Victoria faces as our population balloons. In other words, we're just as buggered as most cities.


    Still, it can be a great place.
  3. gogreener Posted 12:58 pm
    07 May 2008

    Have just visited MelbourneI spent a week in Melbourne recently and was really impressed with the number of cyclists and how good the trams were. There was a lot of life in the city - people everywhere at all hours, big shops, little shops, bars and restaurants all over the place.

    ---- ---- ----

    Go Greener, Australia - you know you want to.
  4. Tasermons Partner Posted 3:47 pm
    07 May 2008

    I remember Melbourne......fantastic place to visit.
    Also would recommend Adelaide.  Beautiful, master planned city around a series of parks, greenbelts, and common spaces.
  5. Colin Wright Posted 4:10 pm
    07 May 2008

    Cafe culture?Damn Aussies. What have they got against Starbucks?
  6. Black Wallaby Posted 5:26 pm
    07 May 2008

    Starbucks?We've even got some of that shit in Melbourne.  There's lots of choice: Hard Rock Cafe, Damn Americanis or their franchisees are in there for any shy people a bit scared of cosmopolitana.
  7. tiffanylove Posted 5:58 pm
    07 May 2008

    tiffanyI agree with you.I would buy tiffany jewelry can you give ad me?

    love tiffany jewelry.
  8. JJ Posted 7:00 pm
    07 May 2008

    Don't be fooled!This whole film is shot in the inner suburbs.  Melbourne's dirty little secret... the SPRAWL.  Some of the worst in the world.
  9. Black Wallaby Posted 8:13 pm
    07 May 2008

    What's your grudge GJP?I live in the North East, (Montmorency), and I think it is lovely.
    Nearby are mountains and beautiful forests including rainforest.
    have you checked-out the areas immediately outside of downtown Detroit, Denver, LA and a few etc's?
    I can ride my bike along the Plenty River and Yarra river trails in continuous parkland for some 40Km into the brilliant Southbank Area in the City.  I can also go outwards a long way to say Diamond Creek, all in parkland.
    Any city of about 4 million has suburbs.  In the case of Melbourne's Western suburbs, for some reason beyond my ken they do not plant many trees, but in the East it is very leafy.

    take your pick!
    What is your choice in where you live?

    Maybe you should move to Adelaide?
  10. Black Wallaby Posted 8:26 pm
    07 May 2008

    Oh and furthermore GJPIf I want to, I can walk from my door and train into the city in about 40 minutes, or drive-in and park off-peak in about 25 minutes.

    We have a magnificent State Library, botanic gardens, Myer music bowl, concert hall, and, and,and......what's your gripe again?
  11. JJ Posted 3:22 pm
    16 May 2008

    SprawlWow - black wallaby you are pretty defensive.
    My comment was in regards to the lack of a complete picture in the original post/video, not a discussion on the merits of the city.
    Melbourne has VERY low population density.  Yes every city has suburbs, but the 4mil people in Melbourne don't need to span out 40+k on either side at a density of 496 people/sq km (for example compare this with Los Angeles at 3,168 people/sq km or Paris at 24,783 people/sq km). This sprawl is at the expense of those beautiful forests you mentioned, and very rare native grasslands on the fringes of the city.  
    The video portrays a revitalisation of the city centre (which I am all for - esp love the work currently happening in the city on bike lanes), but its not a great environmental outcome if all those people shown visiting the laneways in the city centre are travelling 50K to do so because their own outer suburbs are developed without complete services.  It is  because I have seen Detroit and LA that I am concerned about this problem.  Melbourne 2030 was an attempt to deal with this problem, but its not working particularly well as the currently developing suburbs (the West is a prime case) are being developed without adequate services, local employment opportunities or quality public transport - which leaves people no option but to jump into their cars and drive into the city - not a great outcome for the environment.
  12. Black Wallaby Posted 9:01 pm
    22 May 2008

    Suburban developmentGJP, I understand where you are coming from, and the concern about infrastructure.  I think it is well founded, however I don't think you can defeat what has evolved.  Suburbian Melburnians love their green spaces (corridors) and large housing blocks.
    The solution is to improve the suburban infrastucture and employment opportunities, so that there is no need to commute to the centre.
    I for one in Montmorency in the North East, am totally pissed-off with 2030 intentions.  We have a railway station and nice shopping village, and more and more unit developments, and more and more cars being parked all-day in nearby streets on both sides so that it is give way to one-lane other traffic by courtesy. One has to make circuits of the village to park, or some F-wits just sit there stopping traffic waiting for a car to leave.  (AAARRGHH!!!)
    GJP, you can stuff suburban 2030 up your left nostril, and anyway, it has nothing to do with our wonderful city centre!  (And what visitors might like to see...... and other parts of Victoria)

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement