Makah's Mark

Three Makah tribe members plead guilty in whale hunt 4

Photo: bbum

Three members of the Washington state Makah tribe who were charged with killing a gray whale in the fall have pled guilty to a misdemeanor charge of violating the Marine Mammal Protection Act. In return, prosecutors will recommend probation instead of jail time. The men had originally declined the plea deal because it could have prevented them from participating in legal whale hunting while on probation, but the three pled guilty after that stipulation was dropped. Two other Makah members involved in the whale hunt declined the plea deal and will go to trial as soon as next week.

sources:

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Tasermons Partner Posted 4:33 am
    31 Mar 2008

    In a way, it's good thing......the tribe has now little hope of actually holding any legal whale hunts in the future.
  2. caniscandida Posted 6:04 am
    31 Mar 2008

    This is tricky.(Not the title of the post, by the way, which is obviously by DR, remembering his Old Kentucky Home.)
    The single gray whale who was put to death last year, in what was clearly most inhumane circumstances, was, fortunately, not the sole hope of the species, or even of the local population.
    Right now, it is important for everybody to BACK OFF from the Makah community.  We MUST give them time to work out not just the law but the ethics --- which plainly they want to do, amidst great public embarrassment.
    It is one of the failings of our civilization, that we do not usually acknowledge the great good that comes with conducting ourselves well.  We emphasize our personal pleasure, our personal enjoyment of what wealth we have, up to the point where it might intrude upon the convenience of our neighbor.  But we say too little about the positive value of doing nice things.
    It is up to the Makah, right now, men and women, of all ages, to continue thinking about what they value, over against us, the Euro-American tyrants, now and again benevolent.
    Hopefully they will understand that "doing nice things" overcomes standing up in adolescent destructive protest against us tyrants.
    And, hopefully, we may learn that lesson too.
  3. Wolverine Posted 9:20 am
    31 Mar 2008

    Non-Necessary Killing Is A Human DefectBy insisting on killing whales, which are not a natural prey species, the Makah show that, at least in this, they're just as bad as anyone else.  The claim that killing whales is a traditional ritual has no merit.  What if killing babies was a traditional ritual?  The only excuse for killing is to eat, and the only species that should be killed for that purpose are prey species (fish, elk, deer, etc.).
    I'm normally a very strong supporter of traditional indigenous people, but on this issue we part ways.
  4. spaceshaper's avatar

    spaceshaper Posted 11:46 am
    31 Mar 2008

    Shout-out to Canis!I saw you slip in that "who" for the gray whale.
    I like.

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement