Is it still disinformation if the speaker believes it's true?
Bush’s keynote at WIREC surpasses misinformation 5
Joseph Romm is the editor of Climate Progress and a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress.
Related Stories
Add a Comment
You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.
Comments
View as Flat
Sir Oolius Posted 6:40 am
07 Mar 2008
Permalink
Pangolin Posted 8:25 am
07 Mar 2008
I'm an agnostic but my only temptation to religion is the hope that someday people like him are held accountable for their actions by a higher power. If only George W. Bush could feel, in real time, the pain, despair and frustration he has, and will cause, literally billions of people.
The worst of his lies involve the denial and delay of action on climate change. That has put billions of people at risk.
Put the Carbon Back
Permalink
gmobus Posted 4:24 am
09 Mar 2008
So Bush may just be a victim of his own beliefs and we already know he is averse to actually learning anything that might go against any of those beliefs. Therein lies the key, however.
Unfortunately so it is with most people. I'd venture to say all people most of the time. We all have beliefs about the world and how it works. We believe those beliefs are based on reality and evidence. But the real reality is we are a priori biased when it comes to paying attention to evidence that supports our beliefs and ignoring evidence that doesn't. How do you know the truth?
For my part I have found myself to be wrong in some cherished beliefs even in matters based on scientific knowledge. These days I question everything.
George
http://www.questioneverything.typepad.com/
George Mobus,
Associate Professor, Institute of Technology,
University of Washington Tacoma,
and Professional Student for Life
Permalink
Colin Wright Posted 5:00 am
09 Mar 2008
"She tells us that pathological liars have a surprising advantage over normal people: they are better at making connections between ideas in different parts of their brain."
"Psychologist Joanna Starek tells us that swimmers who lie to themselves swim faster than those who do not. And we explore the power of self-deception to make us more successful, and happier, people. "
I'd also recommend the video of the Chomsky/Trivers interchange. Self-deception may be rooted in a biological strategy to intimidate competitors!
Permalink
edarnold41 Posted 5:30 am
10 Mar 2008
Professor, thank you for interjecting a rare breath of fresh air into the miasma of personal attacks and vindictiveness that passes for political discussion these days. It's not that there is no such thing as an objective reality, but that what we make of the deluge of second-, third-, and fourth-hand information that we receive daily depends largely on what we are primed to believe, based on our world view and past experience.
However, if you receive any packages addressed from some of the denizens of this newsgroup, I would strongly advise that you contact your friendly local bomb squad. True believers just can't stand being told they may not be in possession of the One Truth.
Best wishes
Permalink