Organic farmers in Africa fear for their livelihoods as U.K. frets over food miles
Small-scale organic farmers in Kenya and other African countries are waiting anxiously to find out whether the U.K.'s main organic certifier, the Soil Association, will withdraw organic certification from food items that are flown in from far-flung regions. Concerned that the air-freighting of food contributes to global warming, the Soil Association has been contemplating the move as a way to get Brits to buy local. Critics of the proposal say it could destroy the livelihoods of tens of thousands of Africans who work on organic farms. Critics also question the assumption that food produced in Britain has a lower carbon footprint than food flown in from developing countries, noting that British farmers may heat greenhouses in cold climates, use tractors, and drive to their fields in cars. Says Elijah Koinange of the Organic Farmers' Group in Kenya, "They say our products are polluted, but the consumers take jets and create much more pollution than we do."
straight to the source: The Times, Jonathan Clayton, 02 Aug 2007
straight to the source: The Guardian, The Observer, Aidan Hartley, 15 Jul 2007
see also, in Grist: African farmers fear impact of U.K. supermarkets buying local
Comments
View as Flat
wiscidea Posted 6:56 am
03 Aug 2007
(1) Shouldn't African farmers be encouraged to sell their organic produce to their neighbors? If they earn more exporting it, there must be some other problem there.
(2) Are "environmentalists" going to decide its okay to contribute to global climate change as long as you are supporting economic development in poor nations? Now that's an interesting moral problem. And it undermines much of their other policies.
(3) Why doesn't the British organization just establish a maximum net carbon dioxide emission standard -- due to transport or heating requirements -- for each product? Seems simple enough.
Permalink