First as tragedy, then as farce?

Coal electricity prices: the new gas prices 3

In the next few years, Americans who have grown accustomed to some of the cheapest power in the world will start to see their rates rise, sharply, mainly because coal is rapidly getting more expensive.

Here's a preview:

COLUMBUS, Ohio -- American Electric Power said Thursday it must raise electricity rates 45 percent for its nearly 1.5 million customers in Ohio over the next three years, to cover soaring coal prices and the cost of modernizing its systems to keep them reliable.

...

"The fact is that coal has doubled in cost in the last year alone, dramatically affecting AEP Ohio's costs," Joe Hamrock, AEP Ohio president and chief operating officer, said in a statement.

Here's another:

Local electric customers are very likely to see their power bills go up starting Oct. 1, perhaps by the largest margin in 30 years.

...

On Wednesday, TVA Chief Executive Officer and President Tom Kilgore said that rising production costs will drive up the price it charges local distributors for that power. TVA is allowed to make such fuel cost adjustments quarterly, and this one could increase individual bills by 10 percent to 20 percent, Kilgore said. A 15 percent boost would be TVA's biggest rate jump since 1977.

That means an extra $12 to $25 charge per month for the average household, he said. Local utilities expect to pass that increase directly on to their customers.

...

TVA gets most of its energy from burning coal, and coal prices have more than doubled in the United States since December, according to TVA. The utility spent more than $2 billion last year on coal.

After gas prices, electricity bills are probably the most salient energy price indicator for average folk (albeit a distant second), so the current gas price hullabaloo offers a decent preview of what we can expect.

There will be outrage. There will be demands for increased mining. (Mine here! Mine now!) There will be Republican demagoguery on behalf of coal companies (and as a bonus, coal-state Democratic demagoguery too). There will be promises that coal mining and burning aren't like they used to be, because these days super shiny technology makes them clean. There will be expert testimony saying that coal prices are rising because of structural economic forces that won't be affected by an uptick in mining; that testimony will be disregarded by the demagogues. Greens and their legislative friends will push back with a scattered, incoherent message that involves half capitulation to mining and half boosterism of alternatives.

How will it all shake out?

Well, let's wait and see how the gas-price thing goes. That will tell us a lot.

David Roberts is staff writer for Grist. You can follow his Twitter feed at twitter.com/drgrist.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. sunflower's avatar

    sunflower Posted 4:03 am
    08 Aug 2008

    Black DeathSo killing the planet is getting more expensive.
    Burning coal is a crime.
  2. Liz Borkowski Posted 5:39 am
    08 Aug 2008

    the cost of coal-mine safetyIf we get an administration that actually wants to enforce mine-safety laws - or even make some new regulations, say in response to the continuing problem of black lung - the coal mines that are currently cutting corners to save money might have to pass additional safety expenses on to customers, too.
  3. Jonas Posted 6:46 am
    08 Aug 2008

    At last!Good of Grist to cover rising coal prices. International contracts for thermal coal show a three-fold increase in prices (many contracts now going at $150/t). Coking coal is off even worse (some contracts at $300/t).
    Main factors: key supply disruptions (flooding in Australia, power outages in SA, hyper-demand in China and India, commodity speculation).
    The good thing: some renewables (wind, biomass, CSP) are going to beat coal on their own merits as long as the current 'perfect storm' in the coal market endures (most analysts predict the market to remain tight until 2010).
    The bad thing: the big coal users are scrambling for new easy coal blocks, notably in Africa and SEAsia (latest news: India's giant state-owned CIL announced a few days ago it is going prospecting in Mozambique & Malawi. Indonesia is opening up more blocks.)
    The problem is that the coal resource base is too big for these high prices to endure over the medium term. So in all likeliness, current high prices will only boost investments in more coal production capacity.
    The situation is very different from oil, which has a real 'peak' problem, in that the resource base is shrinking rapidly.

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement