Green Groups Doing a 'Face Plant'

Two coal plants given go-ahead by green groups after concessions negotiated 5

Environmental groups dropped their opposition to two different coal-fired power plant expansion projects in Wisconsin and Texas this week after the utilities agreed to a range of concessions designed to limit the environmental impacts of the plants. In Texas, power company NRG reached an agreement with Texas Clean Air Cities Coalition and the Environmental Defense Fund that requires the company to offset or sequester half of its carbon dioxide emissions until federal climate legislation is passed; cap the levels of mercury, nitrogen oxides, and sulfur dioxide the facility can emit; reduce the coal plant's use of water by over half, as well as other measures. In Wisconsin, the Sierra Club and Clean Wisconsin dropped their legal challenges to a coal-fired power plant's expansion in exchange for utility We Energies agreeing to retire two older coal plants in Michigan by 2012 and agreeing to support legislation increasing Wisconsin's renewable-energy standard to 25 percent by 2025. "We've been fighting for more than seven years ... It's time to put this [plant] behind us and focus on the other ones that are in the pipeline," said Bruce Nilles of the Sierra Club.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Montana Green Posted 4:35 am
    07 Aug 2008

    Promises, promisesJust curious about the promises made by the coal industry to shut down two Michigan plants in 2012 and to support 25 by 25 legislation in Wisconsin.  Having been an environmental lobbyist in Montana for more than 20 years, I've seen industry promises on legislation before -- and most of them go the way of a wink and nod and lo and behold, the bill mysteriously dies or is grievously amended despite the industry "support."
    Seriously, how will the Sierra Club hold the utilities to their promise to close down those plants?  Do they have a written contractual agreement with millions in penalties if they don't close them?  Given the current energy mania in the country, why oh why would the Sierra Club expect that, four years from now, they won't be told "we can't close these plants -- it would only drive up energy costs to consumers?"
    Industry promises like these are easy to make and even easier to break due to "changing conditions."
    But I'd be interested to see just how solid and binding these "agreements" are -- as in, do you folks have anything in writing you'd be willing to post?
  2. Wolverine Posted 5:33 am
    07 Aug 2008

    Wisconsin Agreement Good, Texas One BadThe Wisconsin agreement, assuming that its terms will be performed, should reduce air pollution and consumption of coal.  However, the Texas agreement might add to air pollution and will definitely increase consumption of coal, and should not be supported at all.  But as was discussed on another thread recently, groups like EDF often sell out and are on the wrong side of some issues.
  3. Delay And Deny's avatar

    Delay And Deny Posted 7:04 am
    07 Aug 2008

    Sanity Reigns!

    Greens have made the first step in rational dialog.
    Now the "other side" must live up to its promises...

  4. Pandonodrim Posted 2:21 am
    11 Aug 2008

    The Fight Goes OnPublic Citizen and other groups are still fighting the NRG plant here in Texas, we haven't let them off that easily!
  5. pacinopeer Posted 7:59 pm
    13 Aug 2008

    tiffany-jewelrywe supply many kinds of tiffany jewelry,such as

    Tiffany ring,

    tiffany earrings,

    tiffany necklaces,

    tiffnay pendants,

    Tiffany Bracelets,

    andTiffany Accessories. we hope you can enjoy shopping
    in http://www.tiffanysilvers.co.uk
    Are these Tiffany and Company Tiffany Bracelet,Tiffany Ring realy Tiffany and Company or are they a knock off of the real
    one? Tiffany jewelry and diamonds
    provider.Selections include silver rings, silver necklaces and the other tiffany jewelry
    RealExams Practice Engine help you to pass popular

    IT certification exams from Microsoft,

    Oracle, IBM,

    SUN, HP,Nortel etc at your
    first try.

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement