Dear Umbra,
My family is a big fan of dripless candles. They're beautiful and don't provide piles of wax that tempt fingers into creating little messes. Can you tell us how these candles work and if they are environmentally "safe"?
Anna Ruth
New York, N.Y.
Dearest Anna,
For me, playing with melted wax was a cherished childhood tradition -- right up there with daring to slice through the flame with my finger. But like so many activities of yore (see: playing with mercury), I suppose that's now out of the question. Kids, don't try this stuff at home.
Is this burning an eternal flame?
Photo: iStockphoto
The driplessness of a candle, since you asked, has to do with two factors: a suitable combination of wick and wax (which, as near as I can tell, is a closely guarded industry secret), and the way the wax is layered. In most cases, dripless candles feature an outer coating that melts at a higher temperature (i.e., more slowly) than the core. When your candle starts burning, the outer layer forms a sort of cup or rim that keeps the melted wax from running all over your tablecloth, or candlestick, or bathtub, or what have you.
Whether they are environmentally safe depends on what kind of candles you're buying. In normal paraffin candles, the driplessness is achieved by adding a lot of stearic acid. What is stearic acid, you wonder? Well, it's a solid that's long been used to add hardness and opaqueness -- pardon me, opacity -- to candles and soaps. It's also used in cosmetics, rubber, and plastics. Derived from animal and vegetable fats, stearic acid has traditionally come to the candle industry courtesy of the meatpacking industry. Yuck.
If you'd prefer not to fill your home with the taint of slaughterhouses -- not to mention all the lead, petroleum, and other nasty additives that can be found in regular candles -- there are more-natural alternatives that will still offer you the drip-free delights to which you've become accustomed.
Beeswax candles are a lovely option. They don't need nasty artificial ingredients to make them smell good, just the sweet byproducts of industrious bees. They're non-toxic and non-allergenic, and it's relatively easy to find quality, local sources, like this one in New York state. Read the labels and look for 100 percent beeswax: these are, by nature, about as close to true driplessness as you can get.
If you're a strict vegan and don't want to benefit from the work of enslaved bees, try candles made from hydrogenated soybean oil or palm oil. (Again, be sure to read the labels, as some manufacturers add paraffin into the mix.) A soy candle will burn longer than paraffin -- 25 to 30 percent longer, some say -- and isn't as sooty. Since these materials are softer than paraffin and beeswax, the candles often come in glass jars or other heatproof containers.
You will notice, if you poke around, that candle manufacturers are quick to point out that even "dripless" candles drip, given the right (or wrong) conditions. Perhaps they've faced one too many angry customers. Anyhoo, any breeze or draft will do it, or even the odd angle or tilt. If you drip or spill somewhere, you can clean up with our old favorites vinegar and baking soda, and even those infernal dryer sheets. No, I don't like them, but you might have some in your house.
Daringly,
Umbra
This Friday, don’t just Buy Nothing—use nothing!
Ask Umbra on trash, toxics, and tots
Comments
View as Flat
Kathy Austin Posted 4:34 am
01 Nov 2006
Permalink
plantface Posted 4:50 am
01 Nov 2006
Permalink
wiscidea Posted 5:15 am
01 Nov 2006
But now for the horror that will leave everyone confused... I certainly don't know what to do...
According to the recent post, palm oil is a problem.
According to PETA, stearic acid not only comes from the meat industry, it also comes from the rendering of former pets found as strays or having died of natural causes.
According to PETA, bees are abused and have their wax essentially stolen from them.
We certainly don't want to used petroleum-based products.
How about LEDs instead? Well, does the electricity come from nuclear power plants or coal or wind turbins chopping up birds or dams blocking salmon migration?
I guess there is always whale blubber. But see the other discussion on this website regarding that matter.
Are candles, those supposedly innocent sources of light and carbon dioxide, the true horror on display during Halloween.
What are we to do?!
Permalink
SMLowry Posted 6:10 am
01 Nov 2006
Permalink
wiscidea Posted 7:21 am
01 Nov 2006
And I forgot all about soy. I'd swear we can make anything from that plant.
I'd say bees are essentially domesticated. We should, however, try to be nice to them when taking their wax... just like we should treat all other sources of materials with respect.
Hey...
What yields more wax...
An acre of soy or bees supported by an acre of flowers?
I suppose one can't really compare, since the acre of flowers, which might include an orchard, other insect habitat, aesthetic value, the actual flowers, the roots sequestering carbon, the lower energy input, et cetera provides many many additional returns beyond the beeswax.
Yes... beeswax is the way to go.
P.S., PETA should also be opposed to silk, since the caterpillars are killed before they break through the valuable cocoons and reduce the quality of the fiber.
Permalink
madmermaids Posted 9:32 am
01 Nov 2006
I know it is going off on a lateral thinking tangent but a few days ago I passed a waxing studio advertising
Brazilians women/men
What on Earth does a male Brazilian look like?
Permalink
Delay And Deny Posted 10:03 am
01 Nov 2006
What's all this then about lighten' up candles and emitting more CO2 into d'atmosphere?
We'll have to run you in for makin' green 'ouse gasses like there was no tomorrow! (And there won't be any tomorrow, if you keep melting the glaciers with your bleedin' candles.)
--spoken by Al Gore, dressed as an eco-Bobby in Old Londontown.
Permalink
willa Posted 10:55 pm
01 Nov 2006
I think in some cases the real cause is undermined by making a big deal out of these more minor issues, since it tends to cast the whole movement as a little nutty. Also, tea without honey just doesn't cut it (of course, tea without cows' milk doesn't cut it either, which os one of the reasons I'm not vegan). I'm opposed to killing insects, but not as opposed as I am to killing higher animals.
And as for efficiency and complete combustion--if the wick burns, and only a small amount of the wax does, you can melt it and make new candles. So unless the dripless candle burns a whole lot longer than its drippy equivalent, it's actually less efficient.
That said, I think this sort of issue is to environmentalism as the silkworm issue is to veganism, which is to say, maybe fun to discuss but possibly not the best thing to go around talking about in public, lest people think you're a nutcase and ignore everything else you have to say.
Permalink