Bailout vs. bull market

New data: Green investment would produce about twice the jobs of Wall Street bailout 1

There's been a bit of extremely stupid chatter in D.C. lately suggesting that somehow the financial storm could get in the way of action to combat the climate crisis.

So I picked up my phone at Greenpeace and asked Robert Pollin and Heidi Garrett-Peltier of the University of Massachusetts to compare the economic effects of bailing out Wall Street to investing in the green economy (they wrote a "Green Recovery" report for the Center for American Progress), and then wrote up their results in an article for The Nation, "The Next Bull Market."

The take-home point: investing in a green economy will conservatively produce about twice the jobs that throwing money at Wall Street will. Here are a couple of excerpts from the article, but I think you'll find the the full article worth reading: it provides some really solid numbers on which to base a progressive, green response to the financial crisis. (Also, green-jobs guru Van Jones ate it up when I discussed it with him at the D.C. Green Jobs Day of Action.)

"There's always a bull market somewhere," goes the old Wall Street saw, and it's a principle that Washington needs to keep firmly in mind as it contemplates its trillion-dollar financial bailout. Today, that bull market is in green investing, which includes everything from wind and solar power to forest conservation.

Since 2001, the wind industry has grown 339 percent; the solar industry has grown a whopping 579 percent; both are projected to continue their blockbuster double-digit annual growth into the foreseeable future. In contrast, the Dow Jones average has climbed just 2 percent during the same period, and is only barely hanging on at those levels because of the artificial boost produced by talk of the bailout ...

But the biggest benefit of this green recovery will come from solving a looming financial threat as great or greater than the current one: global warming.

Conservative estimates place the costs of increased disease, flooding, drought, extreme weather, insect infestation and other impacts of the climate crisis at somewhere between 5 percent and 20 percent of global economic output. For the United States alone, that adds up to a conservatively estimated $3.8 trillion drag on the economy -- every single year. A big green investment now would take a huge bite out of the climate problem while we wait for the political stars to align behind comprehensive global warming legislation.

Read the full article here, and then please share your thoughts in the comment section.

Glenn Hurowitz is the Washington Director of Avoided Deforestation Partners (www.adpartners.org), an organization dedicated to protecting tropical forests as part of the solution to climate change. His writing has appeared in The New York Times, Politico, The Los Angeles Times, The American Prospect, and many other publications. He is the author of the critically acclaimed book Fear and Courage in the Democratic Party and has worked in a variety of senior positions in the environmental movement and on political campaigns. All his writing at Grist represents his own opinions and no organization should be held responsible for it!

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Delay And Deny's avatar

    Delay And Deny Posted 9:09 am
    29 Sep 2008

    Small CapsIt's really more about a whole New Economy versus the Old.   Real growth is in the small and midcaps doing things like alternative energy, hydrogen, linux, web 2.0 ...
    Just because the Dow falls, doesn't mean "the market" is bad.  We're getting some much needed correction because Dow stocks are valued as monopolies but most are now in industries that are commoditized.
    Contrast that with the significant IP being generated by nanotech, hydrolysis research, materials for storing hydrogen, catalysts and so on that will be real value for companies.
    I myself have found a few stocks that blanket a range of alternative technology and green energy companies and continue to fund those.

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement