Bad Democrat, no cookie

Obama disappoints 7

Barack Obama, I award you no points:

US Senators Jim Bunning (R-KY) and Barack Obama (D-IL) have re-introduced a piece of legislation that would help create the infrastructure needed for large-scale production of Coal-to-Liquids (CTL) fuel in the U.S. ...

The Coal-to-Liquid Fuel Promotion Act of 2007 enables the Department of Energy to provide loan guarantees for construction and direct loans for the planning and permitting of CTL plants. Loan guarantees will encourage private investment and planning loans will help companies prepare a plant for construction.

Nothing dims my opinion of government's role in the economy more than things like this. Between the U.S., China, and now India, that makes some of the world's largest or fastest-growing economies planning for CTL to play a large role in the future.

I hold out hope that we can fight back the worst of these developments, but it's things like this that will make conservation and efficiency more important than anything. As the easiest gasoline vanishes out our tailpipes, the supply we are left with will increasingly be the non-conventional stuff -- tar sands, coal, corn ethanol. I'm not sure what the carbon balance is for CTL vs. coal-fired corn ethanol plants, but the best answer is "neither."

John McGrath is an intinerant student and sometimes reporter currently living in Toronto, Canada. He mainly writes about Canadian and International Politics from an energy and climate perspective

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Biodiversivist's avatar

    Biodiversivist Posted 2:05 pm
    06 Jan 2007

    Coal to liquidproduces about 8% more CO2 than regular diesel if you sequester the carbon underground as the U.S. plants hope to do. If you don't, then it produces twice as much CO2 (most CTL plants in other countries will not sequester CO2). Corn ethanol reduces CO2 maybe 10 to 18% tops. Neither is an answer to CO2 emissions.
    http://www.nature.com/news/2006/061204/full/444677a.html (subscription required)

    In the end, it all comes down to biodiversity. Poison Darts--Protecting the biodiversity of our world
  2. John McGrath Posted 2:29 am
    07 Jan 2007

    ThanksThe glories of the series of tubes, where someone's always smarter than I.
  3. Tod Posted 4:05 am
    09 Jan 2007

    another example of dem hopes dashedWhen are we going to realize that neither party is going to get this done?
    Prediction: If Obama runs for office, few Grist readers will care about this liquid coal plan - they'll vote for him anyway.

    "Because the world doesn't matter if you don't have the strength to go ahead and choose something that's really true." - Julio Cortazar, Hopscotch
  4. David Roberts's avatar

    David Roberts Posted 5:33 am
    09 Jan 2007

    duhIf Obama runs for office, few Grist readers will care about this liquid coal plan - they'll vote for him anyway.
    Yup -- be mighty stupid not to.

    www.grist.org
  5. sunflower's avatar

    sunflower Posted 6:37 am
    09 Jan 2007



    Amorphous carbon rebellion vs. plutocracy
    Kerry lost when he acknowledge he was a follower and not a leader (the Iran war).  
    Obama can not win leadership as just another follower (coal to liquids).
    A true leader will challenge the hidden wizards behind curtains.

  6. Delay And Deny's avatar

    Delay And Deny Posted 6:43 am
    09 Jan 2007

    Back to 1900 as always

    Leave it up to the Dems to pick the technologies of yesteryear!
    Yep, while George Bush has been funding an advanced Hydrogen Economy to the tune of 1 Billion dollars per year for 6 years, here come the "Progress" Dems to fund Coal (Solid) and Liquids.
    The 21st century needs lightweight, powerful conduits.   Hydrogen is the real answer. The Dynamic Republicans have been two decades ahead of the smokestack Dems ever since 2000.
    Leave it to Barrack to come up with some New Deal Era, Smokestack, Hardhat, antideluvian plan to send us all backwards!



    The Texeme Construct offers international text memetics construction and textcasting services.
  7. sunflower's avatar

    sunflower Posted 6:59 am
    09 Jan 2007

    Dirty Replublican Hippies

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement