The American Prospect is running a contest: develop an "elevator pitch" for liberalism. An elevator pitch -- familiar to folks desperate to raise money (hi) -- refers to a short, pithy summary of the benefits of one's project. Conservatives, the Prospectors say, have a familiar elevator pitch (strong defense, lower taxes, fewer gay people, etc.), but people are constantly baffled as to what liberalism "stands for." (You can read a few Prospect readers' attempts here.)
"Hm," I thought. "What does environmentalism stand for? Aside from this or that piece of legislation, what is environmentalism's elevator pitch?"
So, with apologies/thanks to the Prospect, I'm ripping off their idea and starting a contest of my own.
Submit an elevator pitch for environmentalism in comments. It must be no more than 30 words. Pitches longer than that will be disqualified. Imagine yourself in an elevator with a skeptical but open-minded Average Citizen. You have seven floors to make your pitch. What does environmentalism offer them? What does it ask of them? What are its core values, its core vision? Try to limit your comment to a pitch -- if you want to discourse on the larger issue of environmentalism's future, you can do so over on this post.
The winner -- as determined by the Contest Dictator, i.e., me -- will win a highly coveted, fashion-forward, limited-edition, organic-cotton, still-have-a-few-lying-around-the-office, Very First Official Grist T-shirt (VGOFT) (this is on the front; this is on the back).
I'll announce the winner in a couple of weeks. Go to it!
Comments
View as Flat
jonstahl Posted 8:41 am
25 Jan 2005
Another, less serious take:
...hot showers. I like hot showers. I want there to keep on being hot showers. And I want everyone to be able to enjoy hot showers, too. Because I'm not selfish.
Permalink
wetecoman Posted 12:56 am
26 Jan 2005
Ed Shadrick
Permalink
Emily Gertz Posted 1:44 am
26 Jan 2005
Imagine waking up every day knowing that you are breathing clean air, drinking safe water, and eating healthy food, in a country where you always have a say in how things get done.
Now, imagine feeling confident that your grandkids, and their kids, and theirs, will all wake up every day of their lives knowing the same things.
Permalink
hardisun Posted 3:09 am
26 Jan 2005
we go forth and multiply
(while the filter works)
Permalink
Emily Gertz Posted 5:45 am
26 Jan 2005
Environmentalism is waking up every day breathing clean air, drinking safe water, eating healthy food, and having a real vote, and knowing that your grandkids--and theirs--will, too.
Permalink
jsteinberger Posted 5:55 am
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
Skapo Posted 5:58 am
26 Jan 2005
Knowing what is ecologically right and doing it.
A responsibility we have as the most "advanced" beings on earth.
Enviro-mentali-ty.
"To know and not to use is not yet to know."
-Buddhist saying
Permalink
Skapo Posted 6:00 am
26 Jan 2005
One constructive comment: shouldn't environmentalism be concerned about going forth and multiplying too much?
Perhaps you caould use your obvious haiku skills with another try.
I know I would appreciate it.
Peace.
"To know and not to use is not yet to know."
-Buddhist saying
Permalink
Skapo Posted 6:01 am
26 Jan 2005
Living life so that all life may live.
Thanks.
"To know and not to use is not yet to know."
-Buddhist saying
Permalink
bigdumbhoosier Posted 6:05 am
26 Jan 2005
Only here can we make the sacred journey of life.
Every day, Earth gets more crowded and everybody wants more.
Permalink
Bobbi Katsanis Posted 6:12 am
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
timmercure Posted 6:13 am
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
Galileo Posted 6:28 am
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
ask Posted 6:57 am
26 Jan 2005
Take 1 -
Conservation is about health. We are our environment: the air we breathe, the water we drink. The health of our bodies, spirits, economies and communities depends on a healthy environment.
Take 2 -
Conservation is about improving lives. It's about the safety of air and water... the health of communities and economies... and places where families reconnect with the earth and each other.
Permalink
hardisun Posted 7:16 am
26 Jan 2005
we all drink the same water
so don't crap in it.
Permalink
docwatson Posted 7:24 am
26 Jan 2005
Whenever I'm stuck in a little room like this, I think about our little spaceship earth. Hope we're doing enough to keep it a good place for the next generation.
Doc Watson
Today's mighty oak is just yesterday's nut that held its ground.
And a mighty river is just a lot of little drips who stuck together.
Permalink
glazkrem Posted 7:35 am
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
ornal Posted 10:02 am
26 Jan 2005
...Caring enough to take personal responsibility to protect the air, water, natural resources and natural beauty that we all need to survive and to thrive on this planet.
"Be the change you want to see in the world" (Ghandi)
Permalink
jonmarin Posted 10:21 am
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
jonmarin Posted 10:24 am
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
veggiegirl Posted 2:07 pm
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
enrgywzrd Posted 2:41 pm
26 Jan 2005
It is our responsibility to stay within the zone:
- reduce unnatural use of fossil fuels
- develop sustainable natural energy sources
Permalink
carol Posted 4:20 pm
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
Shampnois Posted 11:07 pm
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
Trevor Nagobian Posted 11:27 pm
26 Jan 2005
Permalink
harford Posted 12:48 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
onkasmonka Posted 1:43 am
27 Jan 2005
"Beautiful day outside" they would probably reply with "Yah", or "Sure is".
Ever imagine living out of a broken down elevator? (I would pretend to think about the question)-Hmm, that's what I imagine the world will be like when humans are done with it-have a good day!
Permalink
Justin Vood Good Posted 2:16 am
27 Jan 2005
Improving the economy by making it ecologically-rational (it isn't).
Bringing social justice to the world (it's possible).
Rediscovering a life of meaning and excitement by connecting to Nature (that's intuitive).
Permalink
wildtrout Posted 2:22 am
27 Jan 2005
Followed by six floors of thoughtful silence.
"Life is too tragic for sadness: Let us rejoice." -Ed Abbey
Permalink
Enviro-Education Posted 3:27 am
27 Jan 2005
Understanding that:
Everything is connected to everything else.
Everything has to go somewhere.
There is no free lunch.
Nature always bats last.
Regards,
Professorlife
Permalink
gracepburson Posted 3:28 am
27 Jan 2005
"You cannot serve God and Money." -- Jesus
Permalink
Enviro-Education Posted 3:28 am
27 Jan 2005
Understanding that:
All wealth comes from the land.
Regards,
Professorlife
Permalink
Micah Posted 3:45 am
27 Jan 2005
"So do you think it's vital we all work to make sure the air we share is clean and unpolluted?"
And if they say no, I'll reply:
"Ok, I just farted."
~Micah
Permalink
Alison Wise Posted 3:49 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
Alison Wise Posted 3:56 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
bigdumbhoosier Posted 4:38 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
Little Hammer Posted 5:36 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
Skapo Posted 5:37 am
27 Jan 2005
Great job and thank you!
Peace.
"To know and not to use is not yet to know."
-Buddhist saying
Permalink
Skapo Posted 5:43 am
27 Jan 2005
--or--
No environment = no air.
No air = no oxygen.
No oxygen = no life.
Does environmentalism make sense to you now?
"To know and not to use is not yet to know."
-Buddhist saying
Permalink
hardisun Posted 7:22 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
hardisun Posted 7:28 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
blueeyes Posted 8:02 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
paaron Posted 8:15 am
27 Jan 2005
Patti
Permalink
sugarwoodforestproducts Posted 8:50 am
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
MegaFauna Posted 3:37 pm
27 Jan 2005
That's my try. Word Processor counts exactly 30 words.
Tough Assignment. So much to say, so little time.
Problem is, enviromentalism has one stated goal: conservation. Neither liberalism or the Conservatives truely have a single invariable, fixed goal, so they can say whatever they like in their pitches. It just doesn't matter.
Permalink
Kira Posted 10:20 pm
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
mperry Posted 11:30 pm
27 Jan 2005
Permalink
Melitta Posted 3:36 am
28 Jan 2005
Melitta Carter
Permalink
Jordan Posted 4:26 am
28 Jan 2005
Permalink
Sean68 Posted 4:54 am
28 Jan 2005
Permalink
Jeff Lawrence Posted 6:18 am
28 Jan 2005
Responsible self-procreation (Don't Litter!)
Love of all life, not only human
Stewardship, not exploitation
Recycling, not residualizing
Watchfulness, not wastefulness
Permalink
birdboy Posted 11:51 am
28 Jan 2005
accepting that humans have significant impact
on the Earth
and that we have both the ability
and the responsibility to minimize our impact,
however we can.
We are caretakers, not conquerors.
a liberal in redsville
Permalink
kaichan Posted 1:18 am
29 Jan 2005
Permalink
paulaboub Posted 12:53 am
30 Jan 2005
How important is a healthy ocean to every living thing? Take 3 deep breaths. 2 of those breaths came from the phytoplankton floating in the ocean. Don't pollute!
Permalink
jdeans Posted 1:56 am
30 Jan 2005
Permalink
Seth Zuckerman Posted 5:16 am
31 Jan 2005
It would suck if people smoked cigars in elevators. Environmentalism is an etiquette of treating treasures we all share, like rivers and summer breezes, as well as we treat elevators.
New approach:
Nature is a huge family, and humans are just one branch. As in any family, we feel compassion for our relatives. Coincidentally, our very survival depends on caring for them.
Permalink
metrognome0 Posted 7:32 am
31 Jan 2005
A) Stop digging.
If you'll stop digging, I can help you climb out of our environmental hole.
Permalink
photokinesis Posted 7:42 am
31 Jan 2005
.Is the Earth getting healthier or sicker?
.Is the Earth really surrounded by cold hostile space?
.Do we need the Earth for our survival?
.To be on the safe side, should we take care of the Earth?
.What could one person do to help the Earth?
.Is this the thirteenth floor?
Permalink
Seth Zuckerman Posted 8:27 am
31 Jan 2005
It would suck if people smoked cigars in elevators. Let's look after our common treasures, like creeks and summer breezes, as well as we look after elevators. That's environmentalism.
Permalink
Rhndda Posted 9:32 am
31 Jan 2005
The earth is our home.
Permalink
nanders Posted 1:54 am
01 Feb 2005
Everybody
When?
Now
Why?
What helps you helps me
How?
Pay attention. Speak out.
Nancy Anderson
Permalink
kensky Posted 5:18 am
01 Feb 2005
Our water is tainted.
Our air is choked with chemicals,
Our food has fewer nutrients,
What will our children look forward too.
Space suits?
Permalink
tcaplow Posted 6:10 am
01 Feb 2005
"Environmentalists believe happiness flows from our surroundings. Whether this is plants, animals, rocks, streams, mountains...or buildings, bridges, and cities, we crave good food, clean water, open skies, beauty, and fascination."
Permalink
jfellrath Posted 6:20 am
01 Feb 2005
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Jamie Fellrath
Columbus, OH
Permalink
liquideve Posted 1:49 am
02 Feb 2005
So yes, by all means take the stairs if you're able, but elevators are not the enemy. Big, sprawling, horizontal cities are.
Permalink
JohnJMiller Posted 2:20 am
02 Feb 2005
The most conservative proposition in American History:
Don't mess it up. Don't.
If you mess it up, you pay to clean it up. Period.
Much Peace,
jonnymil
Permalink
jdnichols Posted 7:37 am
02 Feb 2005
Beautiful isn't it..
Isn't that worth preserving?
Permalink
jdnichols Posted 7:44 am
02 Feb 2005
In my opinion (and it is just my opinion), to convince someone of anything, be respectful and try to provoke thought without seeming holier-than-though. I think this is why the population gets so polarized about issues as a whole. Arrogance and self-righteousness will bring out my stubborn side in a heartbeat. But being respectful... you'll at least get me to think about your argument even if I don't agree in the end.
Permalink
birdboy Posted 11:59 am
02 Feb 2005
the wealthy and the poor;
those of us with power
should even out the score.
Else 'ignorance and greed'
our tombstone will read.
a liberal in redsville
Permalink
photokinesis Posted 3:03 pm
02 Feb 2005
Or perhaps...As long as we're stuck here on earth lets make it nice for all of us.
Permalink
ridleyj Posted 10:50 pm
02 Feb 2005
out into the ancient forest all by my self
and quietly enter the true cathedral.
Hal J. Ridley, Jr.
(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
//
var l=new Array();
var output = '';
l[0]='>';l[1]='a';l[2]='/';l[3]='';l[17]='\"';l[18]=' 109';l[19]=' 111';l[20]=' 99';l[21]=' 46';l[22]=' 120';l[23]=' 110';l[24]=' 112';l[25]=' 64';l[26]=' 50';l[27]=' 114';l[28]=' 106';l[29]=' 104';l[30]=':';l[31]='o';l[32]='t';l[33]='l';l[34]='i';l[35]='a';l[36]='m';l[37]='\"';l[38]='=';l[39]='f';l[40]='e';l[41]='r';l[42]='h';l[43]='a ';l[44]='
Permalink
Kira Posted 12:05 am
03 Feb 2005
This is from "Nature: A Real Moral Value"
By Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., AlterNet
Posted on January 11, 2005, Printed on January 11, 2005
http://www.alternet.org/story/20937/
I hope he doesn't mind.
Permalink
ElaineAnn Posted 6:58 am
03 Feb 2005
Permalink
ochotona Posted 8:58 am
03 Feb 2005
Ceal
Permalink
Shawn Keeley Posted 5:37 am
04 Feb 2005
Permalink
elliotte4 Posted 1:59 am
07 Feb 2005
Permalink
raverill Posted 4:02 pm
07 Feb 2005
RVA
Permalink
sbeard Posted 3:03 am
08 Feb 2005
Steve Beard
Permalink
treebeard Posted 3:47 am
08 Feb 2005
Permalink
Lori Posted 4:12 am
08 Feb 2005
Permalink
Lori Posted 4:26 am
08 Feb 2005
Permalink
Hudson Posted 4:46 am
08 Feb 2005
Animals are my friends. And I don't eat my friends. -- George Bernard Shaw
Permalink
Japhet Posted 9:36 am
10 Feb 2005
"Don't blow it--good planets are hard to find."
"I think the environment should be put in the category of our national security. Defense of our resources is just as important as defense abroad. Otherwise what is there to defend?" ~Robert Redford, Yosemite National Park dedication, 1985
And why do Europeans come over here to see OUR national parks? Because they cut their's down and developed the rest of their small continent. You don't want to do what the French and Germans do, do you? Disregard for the environment is un-American but conservation is part of our heritage.
Jay Els
Educate, Motivate and Bring About Change. http://www.ran.org
Permalink
nebulouscloud Posted 1:10 pm
10 Feb 2005
Permalink
Carolyn Posted 1:54 pm
10 Feb 2005
The actions taken can be interchanged with any number of others to create a whole series of elevator pitches, or just choose your favorite and stick with that one. Some examples (phrases to go after the words "actions like"):
buying recycled products, carpooling, installing low-flow showerheads and toilets, keeping vehicles maintained, reducing pesticide use, using cover crops in the winter, etc.
Permalink
nebulouscloud Posted 8:44 pm
10 Feb 2005
Permalink
nebulouscloud Posted 9:48 pm
10 Feb 2005
Lest it go unsaid, a big thanks to Bill M for the book Enough.
(Sorry about the repeat postings here)
Permalink
redboat Posted 12:42 am
12 Feb 2005
"What kind of world do you want your children to live in?"
The Sierra Club often uses the phrase "For Our Families, For Our Future" which I think is pretty effective.
I terms of political power, if we could label anti-environment politicians as being "anti-hunting", "anti-habitat", or "anti-wildlife", maybe we could through some of the bums out. It seems as though anytime enviromentalists join forces with hunters and fishermen the coalition is unbeatable. See "Guns & Greens", by Ted Williams, in the latest Audubon, at
http://magazine.audubon.org/incite/incite0501.html
eddy out,
rich
Permalink
clarkmaxfield Posted 12:12 am
13 Feb 2005
"We want to be as concerned about the cleanliness and future of the area outside, as we are about our cars and homes..."
"We're embarassed that an average American pollutes more than 5 Swedes, 10 Turks, or 25 Pakastanis...and we want to improve that figure"
Clark Maxfield
"Great minds discuss ideas;
average minds discuss events;
and small minds discuss people."
- Jackson W. Nanje
Permalink
kjhenderson Posted 8:00 am
14 Feb 2005
Permalink
birdboy Posted 10:22 am
14 Feb 2005
If he says 'forever', forget him, he's an idiot.
If he says 'until God decides otherwise', forget him, he's not responsible.
If he gives a finite time, he's on our side already.
a liberal in redsville
Permalink
LauriKayElbing Posted 6:43 pm
14 Feb 2005
How did they make breathable air, drinkable water, and edible food a political issue, anyhow? It's about life, not politics.
Permalink
LauriKayElbing Posted 7:07 pm
14 Feb 2005
How did they make breathable air, drinkable water, and edible food a political issue, anyhow?
Permalink
Seth Zuckerman Posted 10:11 am
15 Feb 2005
You know how George Lakoff (Don't Think of an Elephant, Moral Politics) divides up people's world views into "nurturing parent family" and "strict father family"? It seems that most of the preceeding entries (including my own) are written for people who fall into the "nurturing parent" camp. In the interests of broadening the field for the "strict father" world view, here is another entry for that market segment:
The Earth is our house, our pantry, and our backyard. God* left us in charge. If we screw it up, boy are we in trouble.
* or 'the Goddess,' depending on the listener.
Permalink
godot Posted 6:52 am
16 Feb 2005
Permalink
Geoff Johnson Posted 3:20 am
17 Feb 2005
Pretty bad on this side. Mind if I squeeze over?
Clunk.
Dang. Stalled. AC's out, too. Guess we're stuck here awhile. Meantime, whaddya think about environmentalism?
Permalink
jakewan Posted 6:52 am
17 Feb 2005
Permalink
LauriKayElbing Posted 6:17 am
18 Feb 2005
Permalink
LauriKayElbing Posted 7:24 am
18 Feb 2005
Permalink
LauriKayElbing Posted 5:44 am
19 Feb 2005
Permalink
Hallelujah Posted 3:39 am
23 Feb 2005
Permalink
loneoak Posted 7:05 am
23 Feb 2005
Environmentalism means leading a fulfilling life by using less resources more efficiently, living in intelligently and ethically designed communities, and preserving human and non-human well-being in the long run.
Fastball:
Environmentalism means: Don't poop where you eat.
Permalink
GrimAce Posted 6:59 am
24 Feb 2005
The media need revolution to survive.
Permalink
photokinesis Posted 12:58 pm
25 Feb 2005
Permalink
Catfish John Posted 4:59 pm
25 Feb 2005
Have a closer look, and forget what the critics say. Trust me, your life depends on it.
Good things,
JDT
Permalink
whippb Posted 1:47 am
27 Feb 2005
-Environmentalism is about self interest. You will suffer from bad air. You will suffer from unsafe drinking water. It's really about what is best for you.-
Permalink
JJC Posted 7:08 am
04 Mar 2005
Permalink
BlackBear Standing Posted 11:42 am
04 Mar 2005
Hey buddy, you like sex dontcha? Wanna get rich? Invest in this new energy technology with me, chicks will think you're an environmentalist. You'll get lucky, I guarantee it!
"Sentiment without action is the ruin of the soul." - Ed Abbey
Permalink
thatgirlinnyc Posted 6:00 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
vjbeach Posted 6:17 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
Alan Parker Posted 6:21 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
nrwalker Posted 6:34 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
somersetglobal Posted 7:24 am
09 Mar 2005
Environmentalism looks at how human beings affect nature and how we can protect nature so that it continues to support life on our planet.
Permalink
kevinak Posted 7:41 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
argalite Posted 7:47 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
dave2 Posted 8:11 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
jsteinberger Posted 8:16 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
billpaine Posted 8:23 am
09 Mar 2005
"We have met the enemy, and he is us."
Permalink
irwin Posted 8:36 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
contrarian Posted 9:09 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
ronniehoresh Posted 9:17 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
naturemom43 Posted 11:43 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
naturemom43 Posted 11:51 am
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
clembert Posted 2:07 pm
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
a1celt Posted 3:28 pm
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
MikeCapone Posted 5:13 pm
09 Mar 2005
--
SUVs are squared-out minivans.
Permalink
jwebb Posted 10:31 pm
09 Mar 2005
Environmentalism is giving a voice to every person, place, and thing. Then, knowing the consequences of our actions and making the best choice for all.
Permalink
reidhaus Posted 11:13 pm
09 Mar 2005
Permalink
andrewrudiin Posted 11:28 pm
09 Mar 2005
"Do you mind if I smoke?"
Wait for the objections, and, putting the cigar away, say...
"I agree. It is not fair for one of us to pollute the air we all have in common. That is why I am an environmentalist, and why you should be one too."
Andrew Rudin
Energy Management
Melrose Park, PA
Permalink
garpol Posted 12:49 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
dedalus Posted 12:50 am
10 Mar 2005
Dedalus
Permalink
dschorr Posted 2:48 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
BarbaraLee Posted 3:54 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
monsterzero Posted 4:21 am
10 Mar 2005
Environmentalism is about...
Seizing our opportunity. We've learned the Earth cannot withstand current levels of impact, and still have enough time to do something about it. Together, we'll make it - are you in?
Permalink
KRex Posted 4:24 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
monsterzero Posted 5:07 am
10 Mar 2005
Open-minded yet skeptical guy: What is environmentalism and why should I care?
My answer:
Think of life like elevator floors: (said as we slowly descend)
6 - Toys
5 - Needs
4 - Home
3 - Family
2 - Health
G - Environment
Without a healthy environment, we have no foundation. Environmentalism is about ensuring our lives don't collapse around us.
Permalink
mark4earth Posted 5:26 am
10 Mar 2005
Environmentalism: advocacy of clean air, water and earth as "commons" that are shared by a global society, consciousness of one's own impact, and commitment to protecting and preserving mother earth.
Permalink
marylounoble Posted 5:40 am
10 Mar 2005
Marylou Noble
Permalink
katesisco Posted 5:54 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
hardisun Posted 7:16 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
Tetsuo Posted 7:25 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
dcarveth Posted 7:36 am
10 Mar 2005
That's 30 words, sign me up for the "strict father figure" family style - thanks George Lakoff - and I can at least talk the talk.
Deanna Carveth
Permalink
jillozarski Posted 10:45 am
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
jradoff Posted 2:15 pm
10 Mar 2005
Josh Radoff
Permalink
bthurber Posted 2:58 pm
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
jakplihal Posted 5:11 pm
10 Mar 2005
Trees are lungs, water is blood, etc.
Environmentalism is caring for Earth's health so it can sustain human life without fail.
Permalink
Cheetah Posted 6:04 pm
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
Maxine Posted 11:05 pm
10 Mar 2005
Permalink
saltman Posted 12:02 am
11 Mar 2005
Permalink
moremi Posted 4:58 am
11 Mar 2005
Permalink
kasandrew Posted 6:51 am
11 Mar 2005
Permalink
MaryKay Posted 7:13 am
11 Mar 2005
Permalink
evanthomaspaul Posted 12:50 pm
11 Mar 2005
Permalink
monsterzero Posted 10:51 am
13 Mar 2005
"The stone age did not end because we ran out of stones."
Permalink