WASHINGTON - The United States will not agree to targets cutting greenhouse-gas emissions unless developing countries, particularly China, make similar moves, U.S. climate envoy Todd Stern warned Wednesday.
“No country holds the fate of the Earth in its hands more than China,” Stern told the House Foreign Affairs Committee, weeks before a major climate change summit in Copenhagen.
Stern said new climate rules could include exemptions for developing countries to ensure that growth is not hampered, but emerging giants like China, India, and Brazil should pull their weight.
“What we do not agree with, though, is that we should commit to implement what we promise to do, while major developing countries make no commitment at all,” he said.
His comments come as divisions between developed and developing countries threaten to prevent a Copenhagen climate deal to replace the Kyoto Protocol.
“We have 32 days left before the beginning of the Copenhagen conference and there is still a lot of work to do,” Stern said. “It’s fair to say that the progress has been too slow, especially in the formal U.N. negotiating track. The developed-developing country divide that has run down the center of climate change discussions for the past 17 years is still, I’m afraid, alive and well.”
But Stern said the situation was not all gloomy. “Paradoxically, while the negotiations are in a difficult state, it’s also true that we are at a moment in history when more countries, including China, Brazil, and South Africa, are taking stronger actions or are poised to take stronger actions than ever before to combat climate change.”
He addressed members of Congress as they debate a bill aimed at reducing greenhouse-gas emissions in the United States, which many see as a prerequisite to a deal at Copenhagen.
Climate talks in Barcelona resumed on Wednesday after an angry spat, but negotiators admitted chances for sealing a hoped-for U.N. treaty on global warming by year’s end were vanishing.
On Tuesday, African countries boycotted the Barcelona climate talks. The bloc of 50 nations accused rich counterparts of backsliding on promises to curb human-made carbon emissions blamed for global warming, demanding they slash their pollution by at least 40 percent by 2020 over 1990 levels.
The squabble blocked talks among countries that have ratified the Kyoto Protocol, the cornerstone pact of the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).
The twin-track process was launched in Bali in 2007 with the goal of concluding a post-2012 treaty among the UNFCCC’s 192 parties at a Dec. 7-18 showdown in Copenhagen.
Comments
View as Flat
Billhook Posted 7:50 pm
04 Nov 2009
Not only is the Bush metric of cuts in their GDP's "carbon intensity" already being applied,
but also India is on record as declaring that, given requisite cuts by developed (Annexe 1) nations, both its and China's per capita emissions will not surpass those of the average of those Annexe 1 nations. Thus as the developed nations cut their GHG outputs, India & China would peak and then start to cut theirs in parallel.
This is from on the record, clear statements, as are their demands for developed nations to make a cut of 40% off 1990 baseline by 2020. And the faster the cuts agreed by the US, the sooner these major economies will be following suit.
But with Stern refusing even to state a % cut offer - that is, refusing to negotiate - but referring vaguely to the 4% cut (off the 1990 baseline) mooted in the Congress bill,
while both the officially US-endorsed science, and also developing and some developed nations, now demand a 25% to 40% cut by 2020,
I'm thinking that Obama should be profoundly ashamed of the instructions given to his chief negotiator.
Those instructions can only have been to stonewall to the point of derailing Copenhagen.
The cost of another year's delay is liable to be measured in unprecedented famines.
Regards,
Billhook
Permalink
Juliettelucie Posted 5:17 am
05 Nov 2009
The US is the one country stalling the talks the most, blocking negotiations. China is at the table. It's time Stern stopped pretending they can't see them.
Permalink