Not my window. But this is how they feel sometimes.TottoBG via flickrOnce upon a time, I was full of unswayable romantic notions about old houses. Then I bought one.
I’ll refrain from going into too much detail about the quirks of our house, and of course I’m grateful to have a roof over our heads. But we’ve come up against a particular challenge that I can’t seem to figure my way around. It’s a little thing called window shopping.
No, not window shopping like pressing your nose up against the glass (thanks, wordplay-loving co-workers!). Window shopping like, “We have got to replace these old, rattling, single-paned, glazing-falling-out beasts before another winter sets in.” Even weatherstripping doesn’t help at this point.
The good news is that friends and family and This Old House keep telling us how easy it is to replace windows yourself. The bad news is, we’re pussies. I mean, of all the projects to screw up, is that really the one you want to test your skills on? So we started scouting around for installation estimates.
But that’s where the bad news got worse. Not surprisingly, it costs a lot to have someone else put windows in your house. And furthermore-not-surprisingly, it costs a lot more if you choose a material whose production doesn’t devastate planetary and human health.
The most affordable option? Vinyl.
If there’s one thing that echoes in my head after editing Ask Umbra for years, it’s this: “No vinyl, that’s final.” Vinyl’s drawbacks are many, varied, and well documented. We had two companies visit so far; one spent the entire time talking up vinyl (and assuring us that “it doesn’t bleed”) while the other spent the entire time talking it down. I look around my neighborhood, and everyone seems to have it. I research online, and everyone seems to sell it—but I’m also noticing another interesting trend, which is a sort of vinyl-window backlash. They don’t actually perform that well. They warp and wear out. There are other more modern options (fiberglass, for one, which is a relative newcomer to WindowLand and brings its own set of pros and cons).
I’m thrilled to see vinyl getting its due. But here’s the thing: of the estimates we’ve gotten so far, only vinyl came even within spitting distance of our budget. This is one of those moments where I get a fresh reminder of why everyone doesn’t just “Go Green It’s So Easy and Fun!” Reality intervenes.
I know new windows—whether vinyl or not—should eventually pay for themselves in energy savings. So I figure I have a few options: Keep getting estimates in the hope that someone will magically be willing to install non-toxic windows for a reasonable price. Suck it up and buy the vinyl windows, installation and all. Buy more expensive windows and try to install them ourselves, thus coming out at about the same place. Or really suck it up and buy non-toxic windows and installation. (This last one is, frankly, nearly impossible given our current budget.)
What should I do? Now you get to vote. And/or rant in the comments about what a fool I am. Meanwhile, I’ll be window shopping.
Comments
View as Flat
wyrick Posted 2:23 pm
03 Sep 2009
Permalink
farscaper Posted 2:43 pm
03 Sep 2009
Permalink
Chris Pratt Posted 7:00 pm
03 Sep 2009
Permalink
jaydee2 Posted 4:49 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
BB1978 Posted 6:43 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
wobblie pressman Posted 8:22 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
wobblie pressman Posted 8:26 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
Katharine Wroth Posted 8:58 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
thricejamie Posted 11:01 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
dgs Posted 11:58 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
halwardri Posted 11:59 am
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
themrfreeze Posted 12:03 pm
04 Sep 2009
your original windows are lying in rotting pieces on the ground, the
window can be restored to like-new condition. Our ancestors weren't
stupid...they made things that were durable and repairable. Windows are
one of them. Loose joints can be reglued, rotted areas can be restored
with epoxies, and glazing can be replaced. With proper maintenance, a
wood window can last indefinitely.None of the work particularly
hard, nor is it expensive (once you've invested in a few tools), but it
does require an investment of your time to do the work. If you want to
learn more about this, get thee over to the Old House Web
website...there's tons of info in the forums about window maintenance.As
for vinyl replacements, don't believe the hype about energy savings.
If your original windows are in good condition, and you have a quality
storm window (and I'm thinking wood, not cheap aluminum triple-tracks),
they can be as energy efficient as a modern replacement unit. No way
will you recoup the cost of vinyl replacements in the ~20 years the
vinyl will (hopefully) last.Finally, don't feel like you need to
get every window done at once. Take your time and do each one
correctly. Tackle the ones in worst shape first, then the ones that
aren't so bad. I've owned my house for 9 years now, and am about 70%
done with them. I find it VERY rewarding to take my old windows, with
their wavy glass and original solid brass hardware, and restore them to
new condition. They really make the house look "right".
Permalink
jdontje Posted 12:04 pm
04 Sep 2009
Permalink
swan Posted 2:17 pm
05 Sep 2009
Permalink
bailsout Posted 10:03 pm
05 Sep 2009
Permalink
wobblie pressman Posted 7:47 am
07 Sep 2009
Permalink
Chris Pratt Posted 7:51 am
07 Sep 2009
Permalink
willa Posted 10:10 am
08 Sep 2009
Permalink
bayouboyuk Posted 5:10 am
09 Sep 2009
Permalink
dexter Posted 5:52 am
09 Sep 2009
Permalink
JMR Posted 7:22 am
09 Sep 2009
Here are online instructions on how to make the windows:
http://www.midcoastgreencollaborative.org/Documents/storm_pamphlet.pdf
We are lucky, because a local non-profit set up a place for people to come and make these, which made it much simpler. But doing it in your own house, if you have even rudimentary woodworking skills, would not be difficult.
Here is another website I found, where you can order similar storms, pre-made: http://www.advancedenergypanels.com/index.htm
Permalink
JoytotheWorld Posted 7:45 am
09 Sep 2009
Permalink
ghostlly Posted 10:44 am
09 Sep 2009
Permalink
yogazeal Posted 4:50 am
10 Sep 2009
Permalink
ehsdirector Posted 7:28 am
10 Sep 2009
I went to the library and hardware store - Read books, got out the grout and caulk tools and restored the dozen windows for about $400 to be 'draft tight'... The first window took a day the rest to another.
Later - the realtor stated how much charm and extra value the restoration added to the house...
Also caulked/taped the ducts, blanket the water heater/insulated lines, filled house with blowin insulation, sealed around vents, roof and foundation... everything under $1,500 and about 40hrs (or less time than it took my wife and I to decide on baby room colors, flooring and window dressing ;-)
Have fun with it, ask neighbors and friends for help (also help them) and guide your children to be a little more self sufficient (sustainable) by examples in your life.
I voted 'this is your biggest problem?' on this one...
However, everything counts in small amounts when applied to scale - Restoration and conservation are the key to both our longterm eco-nomic and economic struggles. Your idea just needs to expand to all aging U.S. building plans.
Permalink
Chris Pratt Posted 11:46 am
10 Sep 2009
Permalink
violets Posted 3:19 pm
10 Sep 2009
My two cents: arm yourself with the know-how you need to understand the basics and make informed choices, then hire a good, local carpenter (word-of-mouth recommended) to make it happen before the little one is grown. (Having a young one is a legitimate factor in the decision making process--you really don't have much extra time and energy right now). Start with one or two windows, fill gaps, restore structural integrity, safely remove old paint, and so on--while learning how to do it yourself by actively observing and participating in the process, as it gets done by an experienced person who knows how to handle all of the exacting details--and all of the surprises and unknowns that will inevitably occur!And while we're on the subject, here's my twist...The house we bought 5 years ago was built in 1916, but the whole place was gutted and reworked (very superficially) about 10 years before we came on the scene, and all of the original windows were replaced with new VINYL ones! As we all know, vinyl is horrible stuff, and I've been dying to replace them ever since (of course we'll donate them to be reused, although I don't think that's doing anyone any favors...), but have had to bide our time due to the high costs of replacement, etc., as we all know. We've finally reached the point where we can begin to replace them--one or two at-a-time, stretched out over the next several years--but what's the best replacement solution? We're in information over-load when it comes to the many options and are determined to go the sustainable, "green" route. Can anyone help?
Permalink
Dejavoo Posted 11:09 pm
10 Sep 2009
Permalink
howdenjoyce Posted 7:23 am
12 Sep 2009
Permalink
Jill of all trades Posted 8:55 am
14 Sep 2009
Permalink