Scammin' salmon

Chilean salmon industry plunges into an abyss of pesticides and antibiotics 4

salmonDown on the farm: most salmon consumed in the U.S. comes from industrial aquaculture. Ninety percent of the salmon consumed in the United States comes from factory-style farms—most of it imported. Until very recently, our biggest supplier was Chile—whose salmon industry is in a state of collapse, ravaged by a virus called “infectious salmon anemia.”

Like U.S. factory meat farms, Chile’s salmon cages veritably runneth over with antibiotics. Earlier this year, the Pew Environmental Group obtained some damning FDA documents about the Chilean salmon industry. The documents revealed that:

Three Chilean salmon farming companies, including the two largest producers of farmed salmon, used a number of drugs not approved by the U.S. government.  These chemicals include the antibiotics flumequine and oxolinic acid and the pesticide emamectin benzoate. The documents further show that the farmed salmon containing  residues of unapproved chemicals were destined for the U.S. market.

These operations are located in Chile, but Norwegian agribusiness giants largely control the trade. “The three largest producers in Chile have been Marine Harvest/Norway; Cermaq/Norway; and Aquachile/Chile,” Pew’s Andrea Kavanagh informs me. “These three represent more than 50% market share.”

Now Pew has obtained more information on the nature of the Chilean salmon industry. Note how Norwegian players are using much more in the way of harsh chemicals in their Chilean operations than they are in their domestic ones. I’ll be covering the salmon story more in the weeks to come; for now, here’s an excerpt from an email I received from Pew today:

Oceana Chile, a partner organization in the Pure Salmon Campaign, recently obtained data from the Chilean Ministry of Economy confirming excessive use of antibiotics in Chilean farmed salmon.  According to the Minister’s report, Chile used 385,635 kg of antibiotics in 2007 while Norway only used 649 kg.  This means that Chile used almost 600 times more antibiotics than the larger Norwegian industry.  Chile in 2008 used 325,616 kg of antibiotics.

According to the data received by Oceana, there have been documented uses of at least four antibiotics not included on the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s Approved Drugs list during the past two years.  The Chilean records state that, in 2008 alone, the drugs Oxolinic Acid (25,325.26 kg), Amoxicillin (348.93 kg), Erythromycin (7,980.82 kg) and Flumequine (32,293.36 kg) were used to treat fish produced in Aquaculture facilities.  Drugs that are not included on the U.S. FDA’s Approved Drugs list are not permitted to be imported to or sold in the U.S. market.

These staggering figures raise even more questions about the sustainability of the Chilean farmed salmon industry.

The non-therapeutic use of antibiotics in fish destined for food production raises concerns about possible antibiotic resistant bacterial infections in humans.  Until the Chilean industry collapsed from disease outbreaks in 2008, Chile was the largest source of farmed salmon for American consumers.

Previously, evidence of banned chemicals in Chilean farmed salmon was limited to individual cases and assertions by scientists. The new data from the Chilean Ministry of Economy provide the first official industry-wide figures confirming extensive use of specific antibiotics, including quinolones, which are prohibited by U.S. law. 

 

Grist food editor Tom Philpott farms and cooks at Maverick Farms, a sustainable-agriculture nonprofit and small farm in the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina. Follow my Twitter feed; contact me at tphilpott[at]grist[dot]org.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Spence's avatar

    Spence Posted 12:28 pm
    25 Jul 2009

    IT turns out that Doug Tompkins was right when he started criticizing the Chilean salmon industry in the 90s. It's a fricking disaster.
  2. CoastalRovers.com Posted 2:08 pm
    25 Jul 2009

    Good work Tom,We really appreciate your work and focus on fishing and seafood issues.We had folks from Chile visit the West Coast and Vancouver, BC a few years ago. Not only are the pesticides ending up in the Chilean Farm Salmon Exports to the U.S., the pesticide residues are also wreaking havoc on local wild fish stocks.The impact has damaged local, artisanal fisheries, and subsistence foodfish gathering throughout the Salmon Farming regions of Chile, which used to be some of the richest fishing grounds in Chile.U.S. consumption of Farm Salmon is also having a terrible impact on Alaskan and West Coast fishing families and communities. We are struggling with artificial low prices for our catches, through price manipulation by some of the same multi-nationals that are involved in the worldwide farm salmon trade, and also the worldwide glut of pesticide-laden Chilean Farmed Salmon that is being dumped on U.S. seafood consumers.Wild, pristine Alaskan Salmon is also being ground up for pet food and aquaculture feeds due to lack of markets. Salmon that we Alaskan fishers can't sell, due to the glut of Farmed Salmon on the market, often ends up in the feed for farmed salmon, farmed shrimp, and livestock feed.How's that for irony? -John FossCoastalRoverswww.coastalrovers.com
  3. Clifford Wells's avatar

    Clifford Wells Posted 2:48 pm
    25 Jul 2009

    It's a rather obvious story about the Chile Salmon Boondoggle, but I guess worth retelling.  Sea lice are nasty and love to thrive in the captive fish, and as populations of sea lice grow, the wild species get them too.  I am not as sure about the effect of dumping pharmceuticals into the feed which dissolves in the wayer, and haven't kept up on the professional papers there.  Let's just say that the bacteria that thrives on sea lice lesions has become rather tolerant to any medicine, which is nasty in itself.  Flumequine, a quinone used by vetrinarians, is a leading example.The stuff that kills the sea louse is called SLICE or technically emamectin benzoate .  That's not medicine but rather a pesticide or larvacide.  It is only approved for routine application to certain rates concentrations under "normal" conditions.  What happens is when a bad sea lice infestion happens, it's an emergency and the fish farmers start dumping more and more feed with SLICE in it into the waters in the pens.  Again, the sea louse has demonstrated an increasing resistance to SLICE and it isn't working very well anymore.Many companies are finding out that the more they dump these two chemicals, the worse it gets.  Isn't is amazing that a small bug can mess with a billion dollar industry, and Big Industry can't save it?  I say let all the fish farms die off and make everyone use hooks and lines to catch wild salmon - if they ever are surveyed in decent numbers. 
  4. prosourcecorp's avatar

    prosourcecorp Posted 7:23 am
    30 Jul 2009

    Too bad, salmon is included in my high protien diet. Salmon varieties good for wedding anniversary dishes.

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement