Survey says

Americans ranked as world’s least green consumers—again 3

Greendex public transit graphNational Geographic GreendexWith NatGeo releasing the results of its annual Greendex survey today, I’d like to point out that polls like this are really an opportunity for America to shine.

Take, for example, the question about public transit: Not only did we score the lowest percentage on public transit use every day, but we also scored the highest percentage of folks taking public transit never. Talk about kicking the competition’s ass at both ends of the spectrum.

We’ve also got the lowest score on the green housing index (despite our best efforts to show up the neighbors with big green additions to our McMansions!). And we might want to rethink that whole Lay’s as local thing, seeing as how we’re ranked lowest in the list of countries eating locally grown food and lord knows we eat a lot of chips.

There’s more to the report than these few categories—you can read all 296 pages of it here [PDF]—but if you want the short version, here it is: developing nations like India and Brazil have the highest (read: greenest) Greendex numbers, while Canadians and Americans round out the bottom ... overall and in pretty much every category (way to be consistent!).

OK, enough sarcasm; turns out it’s my job to wrangle out a nugget of hope here, however tiny, so the good news is that we are improving. Sure, everyone else is too—so in the long-standing American tradition that is Always Wanting to Be Number One, we are, perhaps, not doing so well—but at least we are trying. We are trying, aren’t we?

Perhaps with a little hard work (Americans are known for that, too, aren’t we?), we can aim to move up a spot next year on the Greendex. Surely, we can beat those Canucks, eh?

Sarah van Schagen is Grist’s Seattle editor.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  1. Delay And Deny's avatar

    Delay And Deny Posted 1:07 am
    15 May 2009

    How about taking no transportation?Public transportation masks a gigantic hidden cost for its construction, land use, and management.It's completely inflexible, so as conditions change, the same old stations remain, often falling into disuse and disrepair, or funded when no one uses them.Lines cannot be rerouted optimally.Public transportation requires high density cities who impose a great cost on the supply of goods such as food that must be daily trucked in and garbage hauled out en masse.Contrast that with the vision of Agraria, where homeowners would have 2 acres of land for growing food and enjoying life.   Indenpendent SUVs powered by green energy could operate with minimal road building, cutting across the landscape on dirt or gravel roads or no roads at all.Families could stay at home and transport themselves minimally like back in the heyday of agriculture.Did you guys catch Michael Pollans lecture on Fora.tv -- if you listen carefully, he's saying the same thing...http://fora.tv/2009/05/05/Michael_Pollan_Deep_Agriculture  
  2. Noah Pollock Posted 12:19 pm
    16 May 2009

    This is a fascinating - if a bit depressing - index to learn about. It helps to explain why our per capita energy use is one of the highest among all nations.

    These types of metrics are central in the field of ecological economics. Ecological Economics was established to fill the growing need to integrate the study and management of “nature’s household” (ecology) and “humankind’s household” (economics). Ecological Economics is the name given to the effort to transcend traditional disciplinary boundaries in order to address the interrelationships between ecological and economic systems in a broad and comprehensive way.

    In response to the comment above, while certainly rural homesteads have their place, it is simpy unrealistic to expect urban areas - where most people live these days - to disappear. Instead, we need a comprehensive approach to redesigning theway we live given the confines of our preexisting economy and infrastructure. Public transit must be part of this picture.

    Those interested in these topics should consider the summer and online courses in ecological economics offered by the University of Vermont's Institute for Global Sustainability - learn more at http://learn.uvm.edu/igs
  3. Tammi Posted 3:02 pm
    18 May 2009

     Utah Transit Authority is a Good Example of Corporate Welfare and Corporate Greed in Action. Utah Transit is Number One in Government Waste in Public Transit. Ridership is Down 31 Percent on FrontRunner it is a Total Financial Waste.I have a Public Transit Blog: catmeowpublictransit.blogspot.com

Add a Comment

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Hello, Visitor!    Why not register?

Advertisement