One flu east, one flu westThe
outbreak of a new flu strain -- a nasty mash-up of swine, avian, and
human viruses -- has infected 1,000 people in Mexico and the U.S.,
killing 68. The World Health Organization warned Saturday that the outbreak could reach global pandemic levels.
Is Smithfield Foods, the world's largest pork packer and hog producer, linked to the outbreak? Smithfield operates massive hog-raising operations Perote, Mexico, in the state of Vera Cruz, where the outbreak originated. The operations, grouped under a Smithfield subsidiary called Granjas Carroll, raise 950,000 hogs per year, according to the company Web site.
On Friday, the U.S. disease-tracking blog Biosurveillance published a timeline of the outbreak containing this nugget, dated April 6 (major tip of the hat to Paula Hay, who alerted me to the Smithfield link on the Comfood listserv and has written about it on her blog, Peak Oil Entrepreneur):
Residents [of Perote] believed the outbreak had been caused by contamination from pig breeding farms located in the area. They believed that the farms, operated by Granjas Carroll, polluted the atmosphere and local water bodies, which in turn led to the disease outbreak. According to residents, the company denied responsibility for the outbreak and attributed the cases to "flu." However, a municipal health official stated that preliminary investigations indicated that the disease vector was a type of fly that reproduces in pig waste and that the outbreak was linked to the pig farms. It was unclear whether health officials had identified a suspected pathogen responsible for this outbreak.
From what I can tell, the possible link to Smithfield has not been reported in the U.S. press. Searches of Google News and the websites of the New York Times, Washington Post, and Wall Street Journal all came up empty. The link is being made in the Mexican media, however. "Granjas Carroll, causa de epidemia en La Gloria," declared a headline in the Vera Cruz-based paper La Marcha. No need to translate that, except to point out that La Gloria is the village where the outbreak seems to have started. Judging from the article, Mexican authorities treat hog CAFOs with just as much if not more indulgence than their peers north of the border, to the detriment of surrounding communities and the general public health. Get this:
De acuerdo con uno de los habitantes de la comunidad, Eli Ferrer Cortés, los desechos fecales y orgánicos que produce Granjas Carroll no son tratados adecuadamente, lo que genera contaminación del agua y del viento en la region.
My rough translation: According to one community resident, the organic and fecal waste produced by Granjas Carrol isn't adequately treated, creating water and air pollution in the region. I witnessed -- and smelled -- the same thing in Hardin County, Iowa, a couple of years ago, another area marked by intensive industrial hog production. The article goes on to say that area residents have long complained of "fetid odors" in the air and water, and swarms of flies hovering around waste lagoons. Like their counterparts who live in CAFO-heavy U.S. areas, they also complain of respiratory ailments. Now, with 30 percent of the area's residents now infected with the virulent flu bug, people are demanding that state and federal authorities inspect hog operations there. So far, reports La Marcha, the response has been: nada.
The Mexico City daily La Jornada has also made the link. According to the newspaper, the Mexican health agency IMSS has acknowledged that the orginal carrier for the flu could be the "clouds of flies" that multiply in the Smithfield subsidiary's manure lagoons.
I'll be in touch with contacts in Mexico as this story develops -- and I'll be curious to see whether the U.S. media explores the link with Smithfield's Mexico operation.
Note: In the original version of this post, I had called production at Granjas Carroll "nearly equal to Smithfield's total U.S. production." I had been confusing total production at Granjas Carroll -- 950,000 hogs produced in fiscal 2008 -- with the number of sows, or breeding pigs, kept by Smithfield in the United States. According to my source -- "Concentration of Ag Markets, 2007" (PDF) by Hendrickson and Heffernan -- Smithfield keeps 1.2 million sows. Actual hog production is much larger -- thus Smithfield's total U.S. hog production is much larger than Granjas Carroll's. I regret the error.
The real price of cheap Walmart eggs?
This New Agtivist wants to grow food in old K-Marts
How bad are the next few years going to suck? 

Comments
Post a Comment +
As an American currently living in the Lake Chapala area of Mexico (no swine flu problems reported in this area to date), I have been surfing for further information. Your article led to several AHA moments. I've been through Perote -- it's in the mountains above Xalapa, in a much drier eco-system, like much of central Mexico. I remember it as dusty and windy the day we went through.The whole thing makes a bit more sense now. Here's hoping it turns out to be small scale, but I suspect those pig farms are not going to change much anytime soon.Just a few weeks ago, my husband and I decided to eat mainly vegetarian at home, though we still eat meat when out at times. Our reasons were health and ecology. A connection like this reinforces that impulse.
Thanks for putting this together. If you're looking for a collection of updates about the swine flu from several sources, check this out - http://www.swinefluoutbreaknews.com, they also have a map of where cases have been reported, on google maps. I look forward to further updates on this!
I hope this won't lead to something like SARS and be quickly stopped!
You may also want to read:http://bit.ly/vaC5
Shame on you Tom!
You know darned well your claims are not substantiated by any facts. This kind of hype puts a bad name to Grist.This site says it well
http://www.fairfoodfight.com/blog/el-dragón/grist-cafos-blame-h1n1-swine-flu-reallyFlu pandemics existed long before feedlots became the norm.
Calmate, Bud. According to La Jornada (also linked in the post), the Mexican healthcare agency IMSS has said that Vera Cruz CAFOs might be the source of the pandemic. Here is La Jornada:Indicó que según los facultativos estatales y del Instituto Mexicano
del Seguro Social (IMSS), el vector epidémico serían las nubes de
moscas que despiden las granjas porcícolas y las lagunas de oxidación
donde la empresa mexicana-estadunidense arroja toneladas de estiércol.Rough translation: "According to physicians from the state of Vera Cruz and the Mexican health agency IMSS, the epidemic's vector could be the clouds of flies created by hog CAFOs and the manure lagoons where the U.S.-Mexican company (Smithfield's Granjas Carroll subsidiary) through tons of manure."Don't you think it's news that the Mexican healthcare ministry is looking at U.S.-owned CAFOs as the source of a global flu pandemic? Yes, there were flu pandemics before CAFOs, just as there were wars before the advent of fighter planes and bombs. Things have changed a bit since, haven't they?
I can see how you reached your conclusions based on the information you presented. Unfortunately, as tempting as it is to slam down the stinking hog farms, the Mexican quote differs with research. There is no documented case of human influenza infection from an insect vector. This has been well researched. Not saying that this couldn't be the first, but more likely the Mexican authorities find the US a tempting target for blame.Further, one of the nasty things about hog farms is the amount of innoculation of the herds. Due to close quarters, flu of many types is deadly to pig farms. They use a powerful cocktail of influenza innoculations that covers a huge variety of avian, human and swine strains. Frankly, a corporate farm pig may be the last creature on earth to get the Flu.
The following is from the below link:
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17026-swine-flu-what-you-need-to-know.html
"Does this virus mean I shouldn't eat pork?
No. This virus is named swine flu because one of its surface proteins is most similar to viruses that usually infect pigs. But we've never seen this particular virus in pigs before. It is spreading in people; that's the problem."So I gather that there really is no connection to the Swine flu outbreak and any farms with pigs on them.
I saw the press conference -- Janet Neapolitano and CDC guys and Gibbs -- this noon. No reporters asked about pig farm possibility.
One woman masquerading as a reporter asked in Obama "has been vaccinated with Tamiflu & Renazen" (I forget the exact name of the other antiviral drug useful with this flu.) The CDC guy explained her 'misconception' and answered 'we don't have vaccines against a new flu'. A pretty young woman asked repeatedly if the flu is 'bioterrorism'. Darn it, the doctor couldn't agree, so there goes her chance for prime time.
Memo to TV news shows, newspapers, magazines, etc: Could you please verify that a 'reporter' has an IQ above 85 before you issue a press card? These cretins soak up air time which could be used for info the public needs.
Guanodude: the fact that the pigs don't get it is no big surprise. They're doped on antibiotics and drugs all the time to keep them from succumbing to numberous pathogens (the source of the problem).Pigs probably don't get MRSA infections (Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus) either, but that originates from pig farms and is spreading in the human population - and it is horrible, no joke.
Erik, Orion Grassroots Network
Swine flu is a viral infection, antibiotics and drugs have not effect on viral infections. It's called swine flu because the protein that is part of the virus is similiar to the protein of the strain that would affect pigs. It is not passed from them or their waste. If we were talking manure than most likely then that would be bacterial infections, not viral. I am not a doctor or health care person, I am just getting facts from health websites and from what I have learned in school and books.
Erik, please check your facts re: MRSA
PHEP: thanks, I took your advice to check my assertions and found:"...by 2005, MRSA was killing more than 18,000 Americans a year, more than AIDS.""One of the first clues that pigs could infect people with MRSA came in the Netherlands in 2004,
when a young woman tested positive for a new strain of MRSA, called
ST398. The family lived on a farm, so public health authorities swept
in — and found that three family members, three co-workers and 8 of 10
pigs tested all carried MRSA.""Now this same strain of MRSA has also been found in the United States. A new study by Tara Smith, a University of Iowa epidemiologist, found that 45
percent of pig farmers she sampled carried MRSA, as did 49 percent of
the hogs tested."These quotes are from a piece in a recent edition of the New York Times. No doubt you have a 'professional' take on this.Erik, Orion Grassroots Network
hello folks we're talking about a virus that infects humans that originated from a combination of swine/avian/human strains. no animals are sick - read the news reports. this topic is almost off topic on a site like Grist - except its a topic because of some hyper extrapolation from the author of the post. If you have a science background you realize that Grist is mostly long on hyper extrapolations and short on facts. we don't see the CDC telling us to run far and fast from porkers or birds do we ?