Support Grist
Support nonprofit, independent environmental journalism.
Donate to Grist.
Arts and Minds

Cover Story

Grist reviews the spring crop of green glossy mags

By Sarah van Schagen
27 Mar 2007
Tools: print | email | discuss | write to the editor | subscribe | RSS
Last year at this time, Vanity Fair and Elle tried a shocking experiment: they published green-themed issues. Could mainstream readers handle eco-news if it came in the shape of Julia Roberts and Evangeline Lilly (and, uh, Chip Giller)? Would green really prove to be the new black ink?

Green issues
Covering green issues ... or just green-issue covers?
They could, and it would. After the success of last year's spring surge, a new crop of magazines is getting on board with the idea of going green -- if only for one issue. Glamour has just published a 10-page spread with eco-tips and an in-depth online guide. Perhaps more surprising: a recent cover story on climate change in Sports Illustrated. "We've reached critical mass," says SI Senior Editor Richard Demak. "It's time to address this in all venues -- why shouldn't sports be one of them?"

Four more glossies -- Country Home, Outside, Town & Country, and domino -- have put out green issues for April, and Elle is planning a reprise in May. "For the longest time, glossy magazines kind of stayed away from the green concept because they were a little scared of it," says Tom Farley, senior editor at Town & Country. "They thought that to go green meant that people had to wear hemp clothing or live off the grid in a yurt somewhere. As the movement has evolved, the choices have evolved too."

So how are the glossies evolving? Here's a rundown of their eco-efforts.




Glamour


Glamour
Why they did it: In her editor's note, Editor in Chief Cindi Leive confesses she's not a born environmentalist, but says she's realized that small changes make a difference. If every Glamour reader swapped just one incandescent light bulb with a compact fluorescent, she says, the benefit would be like taking 87,500 cars off the road for a year.
How they did it: The focus of the 10-page spread is on clothing and beauty supplies -- big surprise for a beauty magazine! But green makes its way onto other pages as well, in the form of profiles of dreamboat Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Arctic activist Sheila Watt-Cloutier.
Does it work?: The package seems to hit on many of the important issues that would affect Glamour's mostly female audience: safe cosmetics, green garments, and healthy foods. Too bad the mag didn't follow in Elle's footsteps and realize that any woman worth her weight in lipstick and bangles would welcome an entire green issue.
Our hopes for their audience (circ. 2,250,000): Glamazons everywhere will put down their mascara long enough to find the real beauty in being green.


Sports Illustrated


Sports Illustrated
Why they did it: The SI editors decided it was high time sports fans realize that global warming is a formidable rival for any team.
How they did it: The mid-March cover feature "Going, Going, Green" includes a map showing stadiums in the San Francisco Bay Area and Florida that would be affected (read: underwater) after a rise in sea level. The mag also put together a feature on the eco-friendly Cooks Creek Golf Club, a projected count of ski days lost to global warming, and a creative envisioning of sports arenas of the future, complete with public transit as well as sun and wind power.
Does it work?: The map is highly effective; the only fans who'd want to see their stadium underwater are those cheering on swimmers and water polo players. The editors really brought the issue home for their specialized audience.
Our hopes for their audience (circ. 3,150,000): Nine out of 10 SI readers will buy recycled jock straps.


Outside


Outside
Why they did it: "In many ways, every issue of Outside is a green issue," says editorial green-team leader Elizabeth Hightower in the issue's opening note. "We've passionately covered the environment since we got started in 1977." Hightower waxes poetic about the current sex appeal of the green movement. But it's also the mag's 30th anniversary, and there's just something about leaving your 20s that makes you take a long, hard look at life.
How they did it: The issue includes short features on everything eco, from electric cars to future fabrics. "Green Giants" profiles 23 "real-world" sustainability leaders, including familiar faces like Ah-nold and Summer Rayne, as well as newcomers like an alternative-energy enthusiast turning algae into fuel. There are also major pieces on China and troubled waterways.
Does it work?: This one is green through and through -- they've even donated $1 of each newsstand copy sale to Conservation Alliance. Especially enjoyable is the eight-page spread on a certain green humor website.
Our hopes for their audience (circ. 650,000): Campers, hikers, and kayakers around the world will climb every mountain to proclaim the green gospel.


Town & Country


Town & Country
Why they did it: "We felt we could make a big difference," says editor Farley, "because a lot of times, it's the people who are upper-income who have the opportunity to vote with their pocketbooks and help make some of these products more generally available. [Our readers] want to do the right thing, but they maybe just don't know the way to go about it."
How they did it: The major stories in this themed issue, the first such venture by T&C, include a look at a (very fancy) Manhattan home built and furnished sustainably, a piece on a Nicaraguan eco-resort, and profiles of four eco-rageous women including Frances Beinecke of NRDC and furniture designer Paulette Cole. A special green tips section features notes on everything from cosmetics to organics.
Does it work?: Though Editor Pamela Fiori says she found it difficult to get everything in the issue to reflect the green theme, T&C staffers seem to have been successful. The only trouble is that all the green features are surrounded by ads exulting the consumption-heavy lifestyle this publication normally endorses.
Our hopes for their audience (circ. 450,000): Town & Country's readers will realize Town is where it's at and start a wave of urban reintegration.


Country Home


Country Home
Why they did it: "We are seeing a real interest by readers in exploring eco-friendly choices," said head editor Carol Sheehan in a recent press release. "We wanted to find out who in America is actually taking action, where they are, and what they are doing."
How they did it: In addition to incorporating elements of nature into almost every shot of a home interior, the issue also profiles a group of organic farmers in Boulder, Colo., and tours the country cottage of green guru Danny Seo, a style editor-at-large for the magazine.
Does it work?: Some of the deco-ideas are quite inspired (like reusing sweaters as dining-room chair covers), but covering a dresser in green wallpaper doesn't make it green. And the Best Green Places Report is a disappointment, with just a handful of lists and not much background.
Our hopes for their audience (circ. 1,250,000): The cottage-dwelling set will use the issue's resources to go for that eco-shabby look, and -- dare we say it -- they'll reconsider that second home.


domino


domino
Why they did it: Stylish design mag domino wanted to celebrate "those working to close up the cycle of production so that little is wasted and little harmed," says Editor in Chief Deborah Needleman in her editor's note.
How they did it: The centerpiece of the issue is the 2007 Green List, a partnership with Treehugger that showcases 125 companies and people with "undeniable eco-cred" and "irresistible style." But the team didn't stop there -- they greened the whole issue, from a piece on pretty VOC-free paints to a two-page spread on the perfect organic antipasto, complete with shopping list.
Does it work?: The image-heavy pages offer helpful visuals of the cosmetics, home goods, and foodstuffs being profiled. Somehow, they even manage to make a water-saving urinal look über-hip.
Our hopes for their audience (circ. 550,000): Design-savvy readers will tear out the cheat sheets and tap into their own creativity to make green more fab than ever -- and send old habits falling like a row of you-know-what.

Tools: print | email | discuss | write to the editor | subscribe | RSS
Sarah van Schagen is Grist's assistant editor.
< Previous | Next >
Comments: (11 comments)

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have a Gristmill account, log in below. If you don't have a Gristmill account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Username: Password:

Forgot your password? Enter your username and click:

Shape Magazine

Shape Magazine also came out with a fabulous green issue for April 2007 (and prints the magazine on recycled-content paper). The entire staff saw Inconvenient Truth together.

Glossy is not Green

From the horses' mouths:
http://www.grist.org/news/daily/2000/02/18/can/index.html ...

Glossy paper is usually pretty toxic stuff, both in the manufacturing process and in our landfills, recycling plants or compost bins.  Perhaps we should all write some letters to these publications asking them if they are using a non-toxic glossy paper, and if so, why not.

Paper in general, as we all know, ain't so hot.  I'd argue that the checmicals used in the processing of paper are at least as bad as the resource extraction necessary to feed this industy. Here's an example of a paper pulp mill in my home state, responsible for approximately 200,000 pounds of carcinogenic air pollution annually.

How about we pressure these magazines to look at options for lighter, cleaner, 100% recycled paper, as well as natural inks.

Correlation Does Not Imply Causality


You Gristers and AGW zealots keep making the same mistake in all aspects of life.

Correlation does not imply causality.

Just because you put Julia Roberts and a "Green Theme" on a cover doesn't mean anyone cares about "Greeness".   They may just want to see Julia Roberts in sun dress.   The only test would be to put Julia Roberts on the cover of "Coal Burning Technology Today" and see if it increases sales.

Texeme.Construct(Participant)

Vanity Fair does it again!

Vanity Fair's May 2007 issue will be the second annual green issue.  It goes on sale April 10.

Outside of sight and Outside of mind

Well, Outside magazine's editors may think that "every issue of Outside magazine is a green issue".  However I quit subscribing to that publication 10 years ago because I could no longer stomach their commodification of everything I hold dear about the natural world.  

C'mon, have you actually read Outside in the last decade?  The magazine mostly tarts up Mother Nature to shill for American's commercial, consumerist culture.  The articles inform yuppies about the outdoor Toy of the Month that they should buy to impress their neighbors ... and then reveals the Secret Destination to which they should take that toy (well, maybe not so secret any longer).  Its glossy advertisements push SUVs and an endless spew of generally unnecessary, stylish, and overpriced sports drinks/bars/shoes/shorts/sunglasses/vitamins.

OK, I guess.  But if you want to read something green, buy a copy of Adbusters or Desert Solitaire and hike off into your own favorite local wild area with your own two feet, your beat-up hiking boots and an old day pack stuffed with apples, sandwiches, and juice.  You'll see and experience far more than those who are rushing by you in their color-coordinated lycra outfits while chatting on their cellphones in their Search for the Next Big Thing revealed in this month's issue of Outside magazine.

It's nice of them to publish the occasional 'green' article, though ...

Yes, if these mags really want to go green ...

invite them to join Co-op America's WoodWise PAPER Project for magazines -- http://www.coopamerica.org/programs/woodwise/publishers/m ...


Then there's the articles on Hybrids. . . .

Both Outside and Canoe and Kayak have recently devoted articles to hybrid vehicles as well, and what struck me most was how lame those vehicles pretty much all were. I mean, a hybrid luxury car may make some person feel self righteous, but 25 mpg still sucks no matter how you slice it.

Seems to me a lot of this is just an extreme case of bandwagon jumping. Kind of a "green for a day" thing.

Green Magazines

I think that it is great that more and more glossy magazines are doing "green" issues to raise awareness among their readers. However, at times it can be as disconcerting as a "Stop Global Warming" bumper-sticker on an SUV.

With the possible exception of Outside magazine, none of the magazines that you highlighted use any recycled content at all. Probably the largest circulation mainstream magazine to use recycled paper is Shape, and they get no mention at all.

Out of about 18,000 magazine titles in the US, only slightly more than 100 publications - and growing - are using recycled paper. You can see a complete list at: http://www.coopamerica.org/programs/woodwise/publishers/m ....

I'm all for promoting environmental awareness, but I think that there should be special mention made of those magazines that are producing a quality publication and doing so in an environmentally and socially responsible manner.

-Frank

Magazine PAPER Project www.magazinepaper.org

Vanity Fair does it again...green issue

Is Vanity Fair printing its magazine, or the "Green" issue on recycled paper?

I congratulated VF for doing such a great job with raising awareness with the Green issue last year, and I offered to help the publishers begin using recycled paper (My project: www.magazinepaper.org).

I'm still willing to help.

-Frank Locantore
Magazine PAPER Project director

Magazine PAPER Project www.magazinepaper.org

Read online or buy recycled

We should completely honor magazines trying to make a difference by using recycled stock. Frank, do you have a list of these magazines? I would be interested to see who is on there.

I also subscribe to more online magazines. I know, the energy resources used in posting them may/may not be negligible. But, it's a start.

-garth

Magazine Leaders

Here is the listing of the magazines that we know of using environmentally responsible paper: http://www.coopamerica.org/programs/woodwise/publishers/m ...

However, after postings like these, and at "Folio: magazine" (http://foliomag.com/viewmedia.asp?prmMID=7548), we hear from other publications telling us that they are on recycled paper. It's kind of tough keeping up with 18K different titles in the US. If you know of others, let me know.

Also, please feel free to write to these magazines to congratulate them on their leadership in this area. Regardless of the percent recycled that they use, the fact that they are using recycled in an industry that has not yet embraced stewardship is a huge deal.

-Frank

Magazine PAPER Project www.magazinepaper.org

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have a Gristmill account, log in below. If you don't have a Gristmill account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.

Username: Password:

Forgot your password? Enter your username and click:

The comments of Grist users reflect the opinions of those individuals only, and do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of Grist, its staff, its board members, their psychotherapists, or their aestheticians. Got it?


Also in Grist

The Week's Most Popular


From the Archives
Best Feet Forward. A review of Happy Feet, the wildly successful musical-penguin eco-flick.
The Moral of the Story. A review (and a preview) of the documentary The Great Warming.
Home Is Best. A review of Wangari Maathai's autobiography Unbowed.

ADVERTISING POLICY


About Grist | Support Grist | Job Board | Archives | Grist by Email | RSS | Podcast
Gristmill Blog | In the News | Ask Umbra | Muckraker | Victual Reality | Weekly Recipes | The Grist List | The Bottom Line



Grist: Environmental News and Commentary
a beacon in the smog (tm) ©2008. Grist Magazine, Inc. All rights reserved. Gloom and doom with a sense of humor®.
Webmaster | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Trademarks